Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set Review

First Impressions of Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set

The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set promises a comprehensive set of tools for hunters on a budget. Schrade, a name synonymous with classic, affordable knives, aims to provide everything needed for field dressing and processing game with this kit. This set includes a guthook, caping knife, fillet knife, and saw, all housed in a hardside carrying case.

As a seasoned outdoorsman, I’m always looking for reliable gear that won’t break the bank. I needed a dedicated set of knives specifically for processing game, rather than relying on my everyday carry blade. The promise of multiple specialized tools in one affordable package drew me to the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set.

Upon unboxing, the first impression was… functional. The knives felt lightweight, perhaps a little too much so, but the synthetic handles were grippy enough. The hardside case, while not bombproof, offered decent protection for storage and transport.

Compared to a higher-end set from Gerber or individual knives from Buck Knives, the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set lacks the premium feel of those brands. However, those options would cost significantly more. Ultimately, I chose the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set due to its completeness and attractive price point.

Initially, I was cautiously optimistic. The price was right, but I needed to see how these knives performed in the field. My first impression was a blend of excitement for the value and a healthy dose of skepticism about long-term durability.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set to the Test

First Use Experience

The first real test for the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set came during a deer hunting trip in the Appalachian Mountains. I used the guthook to open the deer’s abdominal cavity, the caping knife for delicate skinning around the head and legs, and the saw to separate the rib cage. Conditions were cold and damp, with occasional rain.

The guthook performed adequately, though it required a bit more force than my usual custom-made guthook. The caping knife was surprisingly nimble and allowed for precise cuts. The saw, however, felt a bit flimsy and required slow, deliberate strokes to prevent binding.

Using the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set required minimal adjustment, the tools are pretty straightforward. Initially, the lightweight feel was unsettling, but I quickly adapted. My biggest surprise was how well the caping knife performed.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of use, primarily processing deer and small game, the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set has held up reasonably well. The blades haven’t chipped or broken. The synthetic handles still provide a secure grip even when wet.

I’ve noticed some minor scratches on the blade surfaces, particularly the guthook and saw. Cleaning the knives is straightforward; warm soapy water and a thorough drying are sufficient. Regular honing is necessary to maintain a sharp edge.

Compared to my experiences with more expensive hunting knives, the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set requires more frequent sharpening. However, for the price, it’s a serviceable set that gets the job done. The durability is acceptable for the cost.

Breaking Down the Features of Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set

Specifications

The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set includes four distinct tools: an 8.75-inch overall guthook, an 8.25-inch overall caping knife, a 9.5-inch overall fillet knife, and a 7.25-inch overall saw. All blades are made of satin finish stainless steel. The handles are constructed from black and orange synthetic material.

The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set has a combined weight of 1.28 lbs. The set comes in a hardside carrying case. These specifications dictate the set’s portability, blade versatility, and material durability.

Performance & Functionality

The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set performs its intended job adequately. The guthook is useful for opening game, the caping knife excels at detailed skinning, and the fillet knife is suitable for processing fish or thin cuts of meat. The saw, while functional, is the weakest link in the set.

The strengths of the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set lie in its completeness and affordability. The saw could benefit from a more robust design and sharper teeth. Overall, the set meets expectations for a budget-friendly option but doesn’t exceed them.

Design & Ergonomics

The build quality is commensurate with the price point. The satin finish stainless steel blades are functional but not exceptionally high quality. The synthetic handles provide a decent grip.

The set is user-friendly, with each knife designed for a specific task. There is no significant learning curve. The lightweight design contributes to ease of use but may sacrifice some robustness.

Durability & Maintenance

With proper care, the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set should last for several hunting seasons, especially with regular honing. The stainless-steel blades resist corrosion. However, the synthetic handles may degrade over time with prolonged exposure to UV light.

The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set is easy to clean and maintain. Keeping the blades sharp is crucial for optimal performance. The hardside case helps protect the knives during storage and transport.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set comes with a hardside carrying case. There are no readily available customization options for the knives themselves. The blades are not designed to be easily replaced or modified.

While there are no specific accessories marketed for this particular set, a generic knife sharpening kit is a must-have addition. The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set could also benefit from an aftermarket honing steel to maintain sharpness in the field. The set is designed as a standalone kit rather than a platform for extensive customization.

Pros and Cons of Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set

Check Best Price HERE

Who Should Buy Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set?

The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set is perfect for budget-conscious hunters, beginner outdoorsmen, or those looking for a backup set of knives. It’s also suitable for occasional use, such as annual hunting trips. This set works for hunters who prioritize value and completeness over top-tier quality.

Those who demand premium steel, exceptional sharpness, and ultimate durability should skip this product. Professional guides or hunters who process game regularly may prefer higher-end, individual knives from Benchmade or Case. Those seeking extreme durability in harsh conditions should look at products from TOPS Knives or ESEE.

A sharpening steel or honing kit is a must-have accessory. Additionally, consider adding cut-resistant gloves for added safety during processing. These small additions will enhance the usability and longevity of the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set.

Conclusion on Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set

The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set offers a compelling value proposition for hunters seeking a complete and affordable set of knives. It delivers on its promise of providing essential tools for field dressing and processing game without breaking the bank. While the steel quality and durability aren’t on par with high-end brands, the set performs its intended function adequately.

The price is definitely justified for what you get. The Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set is a great option for beginner hunters and casual outdoorsmen. It bridges the gap between cheap, unreliable knives and expensive, specialized tools.

I would personally recommend the Schrade Old Timer Hunting Set to anyone looking for an entry-level hunting knife set. It’s a reliable option that will get the job done. So, if you are on a budget, this one is for you.