Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder .44 Cal 1858 New Model Army Black Steel Revolver Review

First Impressions of Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder .44 Cal 1858 New Model Army Black Steel Revolver

The Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder .44 Cal 1858 New Model Army Black Steel Revolver cylinder: it’s not the sexiest piece of kit, but it’s arguably the most critical component for keeping your black powder revolver in action. Pietta, known for their historically accurate reproduction firearms, offers this spare cylinder for their popular 1858 New Model Army revolver. As a long-time black powder enthusiast, I’ve always appreciated having spare cylinders on hand for quick reloads and to extend my shooting sessions. This cylinder boasts a black steel finish and includes nipples, making it a complete drop-in replacement or addition to your setup.

I’ve been shooting black powder revolvers for over a decade, appreciating the historical aspect and the unique shooting experience they offer. After a particularly frustrating range day where my original cylinder started exhibiting cap jamming issues and delayed ignition, I started looking for a reliable spare.

Unboxing the Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder was straightforward. The black steel finish looked clean and well-applied, and the included nipples appeared to be of good quality. The weight felt substantial, reassuring me of its durability.

Compared to some cheaper, generic cylinders I’ve encountered, the Pietta cylinder felt much more solid. I considered a couple of other brands, but ultimately chose the Pietta for its reputation for historical accuracy and compatibility with my existing Pietta 1858 New Model Army revolver. My first impression was positive; I felt relieved knowing I would soon be back in action with a dependable backup.


Real-World Testing: Putting Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder .44 Cal 1858 New Model Army Black Steel Revolver to the Test

First Use Experience

I tested the Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder at my local shooting range, a well-maintained facility that caters to both modern and historical firearms. The weather was mild and dry, perfect for black powder shooting. I loaded the cylinder with .44 caliber lead balls, wads, and a measured charge of black powder, then capped each nipple.

The Pietta cylinder dropped into my 1858 New Model Army frame with ease. Ignition was immediate and consistent across all six chambers. I experienced no cap jamming or misfires during my initial testing.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of regular use, the Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder has proven to be exceptionally reliable. I’ve put hundreds of rounds through it without any significant issues. The black steel finish shows minimal signs of wear, even after repeated cleanings with corrosive black powder solvents.

The cylinder is easy to clean and maintain. After each shooting session, I disassemble it, scrub it with hot soapy water, and apply a light coat of oil to prevent rust. Compared to my experience with other spare cylinders that quickly developed rust spots, the Pietta cylinder has held up admirably.

Breaking Down the Features of Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder .44 Cal 1858 New Model Army Black Steel Revolver

Specifications

  • Manufacturer: Pietta
  • Caliber: .44 Caliber
  • Material: Steel
  • Condition: New
  • Gun Type: Revolver

These specifications are crucial for ensuring proper fit and function in your 1858 New Model Army revolver. The steel construction guarantees durability and longevity. The .44 caliber chambering is consistent with the original design, providing an authentic shooting experience.

Performance & Functionality

The Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder performs its job flawlessly. Its consistent ignition and smooth rotation contribute to accurate and enjoyable shooting.

The cylinder’s main strength is its reliability. Its only weakness is that it doesn’t load itself, but that’s black powder for you! The Pietta cylinder meets and exceeds my expectations for a spare cylinder.

Design & Ergonomics

The Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder is designed for durability and ease of use. Its solid steel construction feels substantial in hand and inspires confidence.

The cylinder is user-friendly, requiring no modifications or special tools for installation. Its drop-in design makes it a perfect addition for any 1858 New Model Army owner.

Durability & Maintenance

With proper care, the Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder should last for many years. The black steel finish provides excellent corrosion resistance, but regular cleaning and lubrication are still necessary.

Disassembly and cleaning are simple, requiring only basic tools. The cylinder’s robust construction ensures it can withstand the rigors of regular black powder shooting.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder comes with nipples included. Customization options are limited, as it’s a direct replacement part.

However, you can purchase different types of nipples to fine-tune ignition performance. Compatibility with aftermarket nipples is excellent.

Pros and Cons of Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder .44 Cal 1858 New Model Army Black Steel Revolver

Pros

  • Direct drop-in replacement for Pietta 1858 New Model Army revolvers.
  • Consistent ignition and reliable performance.
  • Durable black steel construction.
  • Includes nipples.
  • Allows for quick reloading during shooting sessions.

Cons

  • Finish may show wear over extended use.
  • Requires regular cleaning and maintenance to prevent rust (common for black powder firearms).


Who Should Buy Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder .44 Cal 1858 New Model Army Black Steel Revolver?

The Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder is perfect for black powder enthusiasts, historical reenactors, and competitive shooters who own a Pietta 1858 New Model Army revolver. It is also great for those looking for a reliable spare cylinder.

Anyone who prefers modern, cartridge-based firearms should probably skip this product. A nipple wrench and black powder solvent are must-have accessories.

Conclusion on Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder .44 Cal 1858 New Model Army Black Steel Revolver

The Pietta PAF5815 Cylinder .44 Cal 1858 New Model Army Black Steel Revolver is an essential accessory for any serious black powder shooter. It provides a reliable and convenient way to extend shooting sessions and ensures consistent performance.

The price is justified by the cylinder’s quality and durability. I would highly recommend it to anyone who owns a Pietta 1858 New Model Army revolver. Don’t get caught short on the range – grab a spare cylinder and keep the black powder fun going!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top