Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 Review

Let’s Dive into Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500

The Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 is a time-tested scent attractant designed to draw in those elusive bucks while simultaneously masking human odor. Marketed by Pete Rickard, a name synonymous with hunting tradition, this lure promises to leverage a “naturally strong formula” to give hunters an edge. For under $10, it begs the question: can a budget-friendly lure really deliver the results serious hunters demand?

I’ve spent years tracking whitetails across diverse terrains, from the dense Appalachian forests to the open fields of the Midwest. My biggest challenge? Consistently overcoming a buck’s incredible sense of smell. Countless hours and setups foiled by a sudden change in wind direction or residual human scent clinging to my gear. I was searching for an affordable, reliable lure that could both attract and conceal.

My first impression upon receiving the Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 was that the packaging was simple and straightforward. The dark glass bottle with its old-school label certainly evoked a sense of tradition. Compared to more modern, synthetically scented lures I’ve used, this one had a more “earthy” and less chemically intense smell. It’s definitely potent.

I considered other attractants, including some of the higher-priced estrus-based lures and curiosity scents from other brands. However, the price point and the claim of odor masking swayed me towards the Pete Rickard option. It offered a potentially broader appeal, functioning not just as an attractant but also as a cover scent. I was cautiously optimistic, hoping its traditional formulation could hold its own against modern blends.


Real-World Testing: Putting Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 to the Test

First Use Experience

I put the Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 to the test on a mid-October hunt in the rolling hills of western Pennsylvania. I applied it liberally to scent wicks hung around my stand, as well as dragging a scent-soaked rag along my entry path to create a scent trail. The wind was light and variable, presenting a good test of its masking capabilities.

Despite the less-than-ideal wind conditions, I had two young bucks investigate the area near my stand that morning. While they didn’t present a shot opportunity, their interest suggested the lure was doing its job in attracting them. There were no negative reactions to the scent, such as alarm or spooking, which was a positive sign.

Extended Use & Reliability

Over the next several weeks, I used the Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 during multiple hunts in different weather conditions, including light rain and frosty mornings. The lure seemed to maintain its potency throughout the season. I could still detect the scent on wicks and drags days after application.

I didn’t notice any significant degradation or change in the lure’s characteristics. Proper storage (cool, dark place) is key to preserving its effectiveness. Compared to some of the more “fragile” synthetic scents I’ve used, the Pete Rickard lure seemed more stable and less susceptible to environmental factors.

Breaking Down the Features of Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500

Specifications

  • Formula: Described as a “naturally strong formula,” the exact ingredients are proprietary to Pete Rickard. This blend is designed to both attract bucks and mask human odors.
  • Packaging: Comes in a small, dark glass bottle. This helps preserve the lure’s potency by protecting it from light and air exposure.
  • Application: Designed for use on scent wicks, drags, or directly on the ground. Hunters should apply liberally in areas downwind of their stand or blind.
  • Price: Typically retails for around $8.99. This places it among the most affordable scent attractants on the market.

These specifications are important because they dictate the lure’s effectiveness and ease of use. The natural formula suggests a less alarming scent profile for deer. The dark bottle preserves the integrity of the lure.

Performance & Functionality

The Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 performed reasonably well in attracting deer, particularly younger bucks. It provided some degree of odor masking based on my observations. However, I wouldn’t rely on it as a standalone scent control solution.

The lure’s strength lies in its affordability and versatility as both an attractant and potential cover scent. Its weakness is the lack of specific ingredient information and potentially inconsistent results. While it attracted some deer, it didn’t consistently draw in mature bucks or guarantee shot opportunities.

Design & Ergonomics

The bottle design is simple and functional. The dark glass protects the lure. The narrow opening can make precise application slightly challenging, but it prevents accidental spills.

The lure’s scent is strong and earthy, which some hunters may find appealing. Others might prefer a more modern or specifically targeted scent profile. The scent lingers well on wicks and drags.

Durability & Maintenance

The lure itself is durable and doesn’t require any special maintenance. The glass bottle is breakable, so care should be taken during storage and transport. Proper sealing of the bottle is essential to prevent evaporation and scent contamination.

With proper storage, the Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 should last for at least one hunting season. Its simplicity minimizes the risk of degradation or failure. The lure is a durable option for the price point.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 doesn’t come with any specific accessories. However, it is compatible with a wide range of scent wicks, drags, and scent dispensers. Hunters can experiment with different application methods to find what works best in their hunting area.

The lure can also be combined with other attractants or cover scents to create a customized scent profile. Some hunters might pair it with a deer estrus lure during the rut. Others may use it in conjunction with a more specialized cover scent like pine or cedar.

Pros and Cons of Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500

Pros

  • Affordable Price Point: At around $8.99, this lure is accessible to hunters on any budget. This allows for frequent application and experimentation without breaking the bank.
  • Dual Functionality: Claims to attract bucks and mask human odor. The lure provides a more well-rounded approach to attracting deer.
  • Potent Scent: The strong, earthy scent can be effective in attracting deer from a distance. Hunters can reach a wider area with its potent smell.
  • Versatile Application: Can be used on scent wicks, drags, or directly on the ground. Its use allows for a multitude of application methods for hunters.
  • Time-Tested Formula: Pete Rickard has been a trusted name in hunting for decades. Pete Rickard’s reputation gives credibility and trust.

Cons

  • Proprietary Formula: Lack of specific ingredient information makes it difficult to assess its effectiveness. Some hunters want to know exactly what is in the lure.
  • Inconsistent Results: Effectiveness can vary depending on location, weather, and deer behavior. The results can vary wildly from area to area.


Who Should Buy Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500?

Perfect for: Budget-conscious hunters, beginners looking to experiment with scent attractants, and those hunting in areas with high deer density. It is also perfect for hunters who prefer traditional, “earthy” scents over synthetic fragrances.

Who should skip this product? Hunters seeking a guaranteed attractant or those hunting mature, heavily pressured bucks. Hunters relying heavily on scent control should also look elsewhere.

Must-have accessories or modifications? Scent wicks or drags for effective scent dispersal and a scent-proof container for storage. The use of rubber gloves is also highly recommended to avoid contaminating the bottle with human scent.

Conclusion on Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500

The Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 offers a solid value proposition for hunters seeking an affordable and versatile scent attractant. While it may not be a magic bullet, its potent scent and potential odor-masking properties can give you an edge in the field. The product is a viable scent option.

The price is certainly justified, especially for beginners or those hunting in areas with moderate deer pressure. This is a cost-effective way to enhance your hunting setup. It is priced very well.

I would recommend the Pete Rickard Indian Buck Lure #500 as part of a broader hunting strategy that includes proper scent control, stand placement, and knowledge of deer behavior. Don’t expect miracles, but it’s a useful tool to have in your arsenal. Try it out and see if it helps you bag that buck!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top