Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second Review

First Impressions of Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second

The Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second arrives as a simple, no-frills tool, a stark contrast to the tacticool, over-engineered knives that often flood the market. Old Hickory, a name synonymous with straightforward utility, promises a functional blade without unnecessary embellishments. This particular model, a “factory second,” adds an element of intrigue: what imperfection relegated it to this category, and will it impact its performance?

My journey to this knife started with a yearning for simplicity. I was tired of bulky folding knives that felt more like pocket anchors than useful tools. The Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second seemed like an antidote, a return to the basics. Its classic slip joint design, brown wood handle, and compact size hinted at a practical, everyday carry option.

The knife arrives bulk packed, as expected, and my first impression is positive; it feels solid in hand, despite its light weight. The wood handle offers a surprisingly comfortable grip, and the satin finish on the stainless blade is clean and functional. Compared to my Benchmade Griptilian, known for its robust build, the Old Hickory feels almost dainty. Yet, its simplicity has a certain appeal. I initially chose this over a similarly priced Rough Ryder because of Old Hickory’s reputation for slightly better steel and construction. I was hopeful, but also wary, about the “second” designation. I was excited to discover a diamond in the rough, but prepared for a potential letdown.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second to the Test

First Use Experience

The first test for the Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second was a weekend camping trip in the Appalachian foothills. I used it primarily for food preparation: slicing apples, opening packages, and whittling kindling. The blade, while not razor-sharp out of the box, was adequate for these tasks. Its compact size made it easy to maneuver in tight spaces.

The damp morning dew didn’t affect the wood handle, and the slip joint mechanism felt secure enough for light tasks. However, I noticed the blade required frequent wiping to prevent staining. My only real issue came when trying to baton some small pieces of firewood. The blade is simply too short and the slip joint design doesn’t inspire enough confidence for heavier tasks.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several months of near-daily use, the Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second has become a reliable companion. I use it for everything from opening mail and cutting rope to preparing lunch and cleaning fish. The stainless steel blade shows minimal signs of wear, but the edge requires regular honing to maintain its sharpness. The brown wood handle has darkened slightly, developing a patina that adds character.

Cleaning is simple; a quick rinse and wipe down usually suffice. One pleasant surprise is the tight action of the slip joint, which shows no signs of loosening despite regular use. Compared to a more expensive Case knife I own, the Old Hickory holds its own in terms of everyday utility. It is, however, a far cry from the performance of my fixed-blade ESEE 4 when it comes to heavy-duty cutting and durability.

Breaking Down the Features of Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second

Specifications

• Blade Length: 2.75 inches (6.99 cm): This compact blade length makes it ideal for everyday carry and detail work. It’s less suited for heavy-duty tasks.
• Closed Length: 3.75 inches (9.53 cm): Small enough to comfortably carry in a pocket or on a keychain. The compact size makes it very easy to conceal.
• Blade Material: Stainless Steel: Offers decent corrosion resistance and ease of maintenance. It is not a high-end steel, so edge retention is average.
• Handle Material: Brown Wood: Provides a classic look and a comfortable grip. Wood is susceptible to moisture damage if not properly cared for.
• Weight: 0.18 lb: Extremely lightweight, making it ideal for EDC without weighing you down. You will barely notice it in your pocket.
• Knife Application: Folding Blade: A classic folding design allows for safe carry and easy deployment. It’s important to know that this is a slip joint, so it lacks a locking mechanism.
• Other features: Thumb Pull, Factory Second, Bulk Packed.

These specifications contribute to a lightweight, compact, and easily maintained knife, perfect for light tasks and everyday carry. The stainless steel blade offers decent corrosion resistance for use in diverse environments.

Performance & Functionality

The Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second excels at its intended purpose: light to medium-duty cutting tasks. It’s perfect for opening packages, cutting rope, preparing food, and other general utility applications. The blade sharpens easily and holds an edge reasonably well for everyday tasks. The slip joint mechanism provides adequate security for most cutting applications.

However, the lack of a locking mechanism limits its suitability for heavier tasks like batoning wood or prying. The blade is also relatively thin, which could make it prone to bending or breaking under excessive stress. It meets my expectations for a budget-friendly EDC knife, but doesn’t outperform higher-end options in terms of durability or edge retention.

Design & Ergonomics

The Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second features a simple, classic design that is both functional and aesthetically pleasing. The brown wood handle offers a comfortable and secure grip, even when wet. The thumb pull allows for easy one-handed opening. The knife feels well-balanced in hand.

However, the lack of any texturing on the handle could make it slippery in extreme conditions. The factory second status may result in minor cosmetic imperfections, such as slight gaps in the handle or minor scratches on the blade, which do not affect functionality. There is no learning curve at all; the knife is simple and intuitive to use.

Durability & Maintenance

The stainless steel blade is relatively resistant to corrosion and should last for years with proper care. The wood handle is durable but may require occasional oiling to prevent drying and cracking. The slip joint mechanism is simple and robust, with few parts that can fail.

Maintenance is straightforward: keep the blade clean and sharp, and occasionally lubricate the pivot point. The factory second designation may mean the knife is slightly more prone to wear and tear than a first-quality model, but careful use should still ensure a long lifespan. With proper care, this knife should last for many years of reliable service.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second is a basic knife and does not come with any accessories. Customization options are limited due to its simple design. You could potentially replace the handle scales with custom ones, but this would require some skill and effort.

There are no compatible accessories from other brands specifically designed for this knife. However, you could use a generic pocket clip or lanyard to enhance its carry options. It is primarily a standalone tool and does not lend itself to extensive modification.

Pros and Cons of Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second

Check Best Price HERE

Who Should Buy Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second?

The Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second is perfect for anyone looking for an affordable, lightweight, and reliable everyday carry knife for light tasks. It’s ideal for casual campers, hikers, anglers, or anyone who needs a simple utility blade for opening packages, cutting rope, or preparing food. It is also good for those looking for a non-threatening knife.

Those who require a heavy-duty knife for demanding tasks, such as batoning wood or prying, should skip this product. Anyone who prioritizes a locking blade or high-end materials should also consider other options. A sharpening stone or steel is a must-have accessory to maintain the blade’s edge.

Conclusion on Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second

The Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second is a surprisingly capable knife for its price. Despite being a “factory second,” it offers decent performance and reliability for everyday tasks. The value proposition is excellent; for under $40, you get a functional and durable knife that is perfect for EDC.

I would personally recommend it to anyone looking for a budget-friendly, no-frills utility blade. While it may not be the most glamorous or feature-rich knife on the market, it gets the job done and does it well. If you’re seeking a simple, reliable, and affordable tool, the Old Hickory Outdoors Slip Joint Second is definitely worth considering. Pick one up, throw it in your pocket, and forget about it until you need it; it will be ready.