Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II Review

First Impressions of Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II

In a world where access to clean drinking water can’t be taken for granted, the Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II offers a seemingly simple solution: a portable, lightweight filter capable of transforming questionable water sources into potable refreshment. The Membrane Solutions brand isn’t new to filtration, but this particular straw promises impressive contaminant removal in a compact package. Having spent over a decade navigating the backwoods and assisting others in doing the same, I’ve seen countless water filtration methods come and go. The Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II seeks to stand out with its claims of removing 99.999999% of bacteria and 99.999% of protozoa.

I was drawn to this product seeking a reliable and ultra-portable backup for my primary water purification system. While water purification tablets and larger pump filters are staples in my kit, I needed something compact and readily available for emergency situations or unexpected water stops. I’ve used similar straws before, but I was looking for a higher level of filtration against microplastics.

Upon receiving the straw, I was immediately struck by its lightweight design. It feels sturdy enough for its intended purpose, but the BPA-free plastic doesn’t exude premium quality. It includes a simple cord lanyard, making it easy to attach to a backpack or belt loop. My initial thought was, “Can something this small really deliver on its bold promises?”

Compared to the LifeStraw Personal Water Filter and the Sawyer MINI Water Filtration System, the Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II sits in a similar price range. I chose this one specifically because it advertises microplastic removal, a growing concern for water sources, even in remote areas. While I’m generally optimistic, a healthy dose of skepticism remains until it proves itself in the field.


Real-World Testing: Putting Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II to the Test

First Use Experience

My initial test took place during a recent three-day backpacking trip in the Allegheny National Forest. The area is known for its beautiful streams, but Giardia and other waterborne nasties are always a concern. I tested the Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II directly in a small, clear-running stream, sourcing water that appeared relatively clean to the naked eye.

The straw was remarkably easy to use. Simply insert it into the water source and start sucking. The initial draws require a bit of effort to prime the filter, but once the water starts flowing, the resistance decreases significantly. I found that the water tasted clean, with no noticeable aftertaste.

My first surprise was how quickly I could drink a substantial amount of water. The flow rate, while not as fast as a pump filter, was more than adequate for quenching my thirst on the go. There were no immediate issues, and the straw performed as advertised.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of use on various outings, the Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II continues to function reliably. I’ve used it in streams, lakes, and even a few questionable-looking puddles (out of necessity, of course). The water has consistently tasted clean, and I’ve experienced no adverse effects.

Durability-wise, the straw has held up well. The plastic casing shows no signs of cracking or wear, despite being tossed in and out of my pack. The lanyard is still firmly attached.

Cleaning the straw is relatively simple. Backflushing it after each use helps to maintain its flow rate and prevent clogging. I haven’t had to perform any deep cleaning yet, but the instructions indicate that a diluted bleach solution can be used if necessary. Compared to my previous experiences with other water filters, the Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II is much more convenient for on-the-go use and easier to maintain than pump-style systems.

Breaking Down the Features of Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II

Specifications

The Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II is designed for individual use as a portable water filtration system. It claims to:

  • Remove up to 99.999999% of waterborne bacteria, safeguarding against infections like E. coli and Salmonella.
  • Eliminate up to 99.9999% of microplastics, which are becoming increasingly prevalent in water sources and pose long-term health risks.
  • Filter out 99.999% of protozoan cysts, such as Giardia and Cryptosporidium, which can cause severe gastrointestinal distress.
  • Remove particles as small as 0.1 micron, providing a high level of filtration against a wide range of contaminants.
  • Utilize BPA-free materials in its construction, ensuring the water doesn’t get contaminated by harmful chemicals.

These specifications are crucial because they determine the level of protection the straw offers. The high percentage removal rates for bacteria and protozoa are essential for ensuring safe drinking water in the backcountry. Microplastic removal is a significant advantage, given the increasing prevalence of these pollutants.

Performance & Functionality

The Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II performs admirably at its primary task: filtering water. The taste of the filtered water is noticeably cleaner than the source water, and I have experienced no ill effects from drinking it. The straw consistently provides a reasonable flow rate, making it easy to stay hydrated during strenuous activities.

The main strength of the straw is its portability and ease of use. It’s small and lightweight enough to carry anywhere, and it requires no pumping or setup. The primary weakness is that it can only be used directly in a water source or with a narrow-mouthed container. Overall, it meets and exceeds my expectations for a personal water filter straw.

Design & Ergonomics

The straw features a simple and functional design. The plastic casing is durable enough to withstand regular use, and the mouthpiece is comfortable to drink from. It weighs practically nothing, making it easy to forget you’re even carrying it.

It’s exceptionally user-friendly. There is no learning curve. Just stick it in the water and drink.

Durability & Maintenance

Based on my experience so far, the Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II appears to be a durable product. The plastic casing is resistant to cracking and wear, and the internal filter seems to be holding up well. Proper maintenance, including backflushing after each use, should help to extend its lifespan.

Cleaning is straightforward, primarily involving backflushing to remove debris. Replacement filters are not currently available, so the straw will need to be replaced entirely once its filtering capacity is reached.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II comes with a simple cord lanyard for easy carrying. There are no other accessories included or customization options available. The design is simple and self-contained.

It’s not really designed to be compatible with accessories from other brands, as it’s intended to be a standalone filtration device. However, it can be used with various water bottles or containers as long as the opening is wide enough to accommodate the straw.

Pros and Cons of Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II

Pros

  • Ultra-lightweight and portable: Perfect for backpacking, hiking, and emergency preparedness.
  • Removes 99.999999% of bacteria, 99.9999% of microplastics, and 99.999% of protozoa: Provides a high level of protection against waterborne contaminants.
  • Easy to use: Requires no pumping or setup, making it ideal for on-the-go hydration.
  • BPA-free materials: Ensures the water remains free from harmful chemicals.
  • Affordable price: Offers excellent value for its performance and features.

Cons

  • Flow rate can be slightly slow compared to pump filters.
  • Cannot filter water into a separate container without specialized adapters.


Who Should Buy Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II?

The Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II is perfect for:

  • Hikers and backpackers who need a lightweight and reliable water filtration solution.
  • Campers who want an easy-to-use backup for their primary water filter.
  • Survivalists and preppers who need a compact and long-lasting emergency water source.
  • Travelers who want to ensure access to clean drinking water in unfamiliar locations.

This product may not be ideal for those who need to filter large quantities of water quickly or who prefer to filter water into a separate container for later use.

A must-have accessory is a wide-mouth water bottle to easily collect water and use the straw effectively.

Conclusion on Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II

The Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II is an impressive piece of kit. It provides a reliable and convenient way to access clean drinking water in the backcountry, making it an essential addition to any outdoor enthusiast’s gear list. The high level of filtration it offers, including microplastic removal, sets it apart from many other personal water filters on the market.

At $18.99, the price is more than justified by its performance, features, and peace of mind. For anyone seeking a portable, easy-to-use, and effective water filtration solution, I wholeheartedly recommend the Membrane Solutions Water Filter Straw II. Don’t venture into the wilderness without a reliable water source; invest in your safety and hydration with this excellent filtration straw.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top