El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet Review

Let’s Dive into El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet

The El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet holster promises a versatile inside-the-waistband (IWB) carry solution for one of the most popular concealed carry pistols on the market. Crafted by El Paso Saddlery, a company with a long history of leather craftsmanship, this holster aims to balance comfort, concealability, and accessibility. It utilizes a two-piece design with a rear flap, intriguing given the many single-piece IWB holsters available.

I’ve spent years searching for the “perfect” IWB holster, one that disappears under clothing, allows for a quick draw, and doesn’t feel like a medieval torture device after a few hours. My usual go-to was a hybrid Kydex/leather model, but I was growing weary of the synthetic feel and wanted to explore a more traditional, all-leather option. The claim of multiple carry positions sealed the deal, as versatility is key in my line of work.

Upon unboxing, the El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet presented a classic, well-made appearance. The russet leather was rich in color, the stitching looked solid, and the two-piece design felt surprisingly robust. It had that unmistakable, reassuring aroma of quality leather.

I considered the Galco KingTuk and the DeSantis Slim-Tuk before settling on the El Paso offering. Both are reputable, but I wanted to try an all-leather system and the El Paso’s price was appealing. My initial impression was one of cautious optimism – the traditional design appealed to my sense of craftsmanship, but I was curious how it would perform in daily carry.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet to the Test

First Use Experience

My first test run with the El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet was at my local range during a concealed carry qualification course. I wore it in the 4 o’clock position, canted slightly forward, under a light cover garment. The initial draw felt a little stiff, but the retention was secure.

It was a hot day and the leather conformed well to my body, creating a comfortable feel against my skin. After a few hours of drawing and re-holstering drills, the holster began to break in nicely, and the draw stroke smoothed out considerably. The rear flap indeed kept the Shield’s slide from digging into my side, a common issue with other IWB options.

Extended Use & Reliability

After a month of daily carry, the El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet has proven surprisingly durable. The leather shows no signs of significant wear, even with consistent friction from drawing and re-holstering. Regular conditioning with leather balm keeps it supple and prevents cracking.

Maintaining the holster is simple, requiring only occasional cleaning with a damp cloth and conditioning every couple of weeks. Compared to my previous Kydex/leather hybrid, the all-leather construction of the El Paso feels more comfortable and breathes better against the skin. The leather has conformed to the shape of my Shield perfectly, providing a secure and custom fit.

Breaking Down the Features of El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet

Specifications

• Manufacturer: El Paso Saddlery.

• Color: Russet.

• Gun Model: Smith & Wesson M&P Shield. This is a crucial detail, as the holster is specifically molded for this firearm, ensuring optimal retention and fit.

• Holster Material: Leather. Leather offers a classic look, comfort, and a break-in period that molds to the user and firearm.

• Hand: Right. This is a Right-hand specific holster.

• Holster Size: Compact-Full Size. This suggests the holster is designed to accommodate various sizes within that range, but is primarily designed for compact firearms.

• Finish: Leather. The leather finish provides a classic aesthetic and a tactile feel.

• Gun Type: Pistol.

• # of Mag Pouch Compartments: 1. While the description states a magazine pouch, the provided information contradicts this. A separate magazine pouch would be necessary for carrying a spare magazine.

Performance & Functionality

The El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet performs its primary function – securely holding and concealing a S&W Shield – admirably. The retention is firm but not overly tight, allowing for a relatively quick draw. The two-piece design, coupled with the rear flap, enhances comfort, especially during extended wear.

The holster’s strength lies in its comfort and concealment, while its weakness is the lack of adjustable retention and the potentially slower draw speed compared to Kydex alternatives. It meets my expectations for a comfortable, concealable leather holster, although it doesn’t surpass them in terms of speed or adjustability.

Design & Ergonomics

The El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet boasts a classic, minimalist design. The russet leather is aesthetically pleasing, and the stitching is clean and robust. The holster is surprisingly lightweight, which contributes to its overall comfort during extended carry.

The leather molds to the body over time, enhancing comfort and concealment. There’s a slight learning curve to finding the optimal carry position, but once dialed in, the holster is easy to use and comfortable.

Durability & Maintenance

Given its all-leather construction, the El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet should last for years with proper care. The high-quality leather and robust stitching suggest a durable product built to withstand daily use. Regular cleaning and conditioning are essential to maintaining the leather’s suppleness and preventing wear.

Maintaining the holster requires minimal effort; a quick wipe down with a damp cloth and occasional leather conditioning will suffice.

Accessories and Customization Options

The El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet comes as a standalone holster. No additional accessories are included. Customization is limited to leather conditioning products to maintain its appearance and flexibility.

Aftermarket clips might be used to adjust cant or ride height, although the existing design works well for most users. Due to its specific molding, the holster isn’t compatible with firearms other than the S&W Shield.

Pros and Cons of El Paso ESWSRR EZ Carry S&W Shield Russet