Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black Review

First Thoughts on the Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black

The Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black promises a revolution in clay target practice. Gone are the days of relying on batteries or complex mechanical systems. This manual, foot-operated thrower boasts a 50-clay target magazine and the ability to launch targets up to 55 yards. I was immediately intrigued by its simplicity and potential for reliable, off-grid training.

What brought me to the Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black? I needed a target thrower that was portable, reliable, and didn’t require a power source for remote training locations. My old electric thrower was a pain to lug around and always seemed to have a dead battery when I needed it most.

Upon unboxing, the Caldwell Claymore presented a solid first impression. The black finish looks durable, and the folding design is definitely a plus for transport. The materials seemed robust, although the plastic components gave me slight pause regarding long-term durability in harsh conditions.

I considered the Champion Wheelybird Auto-Feed Trap and the simpler hand-held throwers before settling on the Caldwell Claymore. The Wheelybird requires power, which defeats the purpose of portable off-grid training. The hand-held throwers are fine for one person, but I wanted something that could keep a group engaged without constant manual loading. The Caldwell Claymore’s 50-target magazine was a major selling point.

My initial reaction was cautiously optimistic. The design is clever, but I was eager to see if the foot-operated mechanism would be consistent and reliable in the field. Time would tell if Caldwell delivered on its promises.

Real-World Testing: Putting Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black to the Test

First Use Experience

My first test of the Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black took place at a remote shooting range in the high desert. The conditions were dry and dusty, with a moderate wind that would definitely affect target flight. I wanted to simulate a real-world hunting scenario where consistent target presentation is crucial.

The initial setup was straightforward; unfolding the thrower and loading the magazine took just a few minutes. The foot pedal felt sturdy, and the launching mechanism seemed to operate smoothly, at least at first. I did notice the Caldwell Claymore needed to be on relatively flat and firm ground to operate correctly.

After a few throws, I got the hang of the foot-operated launch. However, I immediately noticed some inconsistencies in the target launch angles. Some targets flew high, others low, and a few were released with a noticeable spin. I also had a couple of instances where the mechanism jammed, requiring me to manually clear the clay.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of using the Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black for training sessions, its strengths and weaknesses became clearer. The portability remains a significant advantage. The folding design fits easily into the back of my truck.

However, the initial inconsistencies in target launch persisted. Wind significantly exacerbated these variations. The plastic components, especially the target feed mechanism, showed signs of wear and tear, particularly in the dusty environment.

Maintenance is relatively simple. I used compressed air to clean dust and debris from the mechanism. I also applied a dry lubricant to the moving parts to help prevent jamming. I do have concerns about the long-term durability of the plastic components.

Compared to my old electric thrower, the Caldwell Claymore offers superior portability and eliminates the need for batteries. However, the target presentation is far less consistent, and the durability is questionable. The Caldwell Claymore is a mixed bag and a slight disappointment given my initial hopes.

Breaking Down the Features of Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black

Specifications

The Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black is designed for launching standard-sized clay targets. It holds up to 50 targets in its magazine. The Caldwell Claymore launches targets up to 55 yards. It is foot-operated, eliminating the need for batteries or electricity. The foldable design enhances portability.

These specifications matter because they define the core functionality and limitations of the product. The 50-target magazine allows for extended practice sessions. The 55-yard range provides a realistic shooting distance. The foot-operated design is key for remote locations.

Performance & Functionality

The primary function of the Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black is to launch clay targets. It accomplishes this task, but with inconsistent results. The target launch angles vary considerably, making consistent practice difficult.

The strengths lie in its portability and battery-free operation. The weaknesses are the inconsistent target presentation and potential for jamming. The Caldwell Claymore largely meets expectations for portability but falls short on consistent performance.

Design & Ergonomics

The Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black features a foldable design for easy transport. The materials are primarily steel and plastic. The foot pedal is reasonably comfortable to use.

There is a moderate learning curve to master the foot-operated launch. The inconsistent target presentation is more of a design flaw than a usability issue. The Caldwell Claymore isn’t difficult to use, but consistent results are elusive.

Durability & Maintenance

The long-term durability of the Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black is a concern. The plastic target feed mechanism is the most vulnerable component. Regular cleaning and lubrication are essential to prevent jamming and extend its lifespan.

Minor repairs may be possible with basic tools. However, significant damage to the plastic components could render the thrower unusable. The Caldwell Claymore’s durability is questionable, especially with frequent use in harsh conditions.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black does not come with any accessories. There are no customization options available. Aftermarket accessories are generally not applicable to this type of product.

Pros and Cons of Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black

Pros

  • Portable and easy to transport.
  • Battery-free operation is ideal for remote locations.
  • Holds 50 clay targets for extended practice.
  • Foot-operated design eliminates the need for manual loading.
  • Relatively easy to set up and use.

Cons

  • Inconsistent target launch angles.
  • Plastic components raise concerns about long-term durability.
  • Prone to jamming, especially in dusty conditions.


Who Should Buy Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black?

The Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black is perfect for recreational shooters who value portability and battery-free operation for occasional practice. It’s also suitable for shooting instructors who need a simple, portable target thrower for demonstrations.

This product should be skipped by serious competitive shooters who require consistent target presentation for rigorous training. Anyone who shoots frequently or in harsh environments should also look for a more durable option.

Must-have modifications are not really applicable; however, investing in high-quality clay targets will help minimize jamming. Ensuring the thrower is placed on a level, firm surface is also critical for consistent operation.

Conclusion on Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black

The Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black offers a unique blend of portability and battery-free operation, making it appealing for specific users. However, the inconsistent target launch and questionable durability are significant drawbacks.

At $274.49, the price is somewhat justified given its portability and capacity. However, the inconsistent performance makes it a less compelling value for serious shooters.

I would cautiously recommend it to recreational shooters who prioritize portability over consistent target presentation. For serious training, there are better, albeit more expensive, options available. The Caldwell Claymore has potential, but it needs improvement to truly deliver on its promises. If you value simplicity and portability above all else, give the Caldwell Claymore Target Thrower Black a try. But go in with tempered expectations.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top