Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish Review

First Thoughts on the Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish

The Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish promises to make one of the most tedious tasks in shooting – loading magazines – significantly faster and easier. The promise of quickly filling magazines almost as fast as they can be emptied is an attractive one, especially after a long day at the range. Butler Creek, a well-known name in shooting accessories, aims to deliver on that promise with this tool.

I’ve always struggled with loading AR-15 magazines, especially when dealing with a large number of rounds or when my hands are cold and tired. My hope was that the Butler Creek ASAP would be a significant time-saver and reduce the hand fatigue associated with manually loading magazines. It needed to be reliable, durable, and easy to use under various range conditions.

Upon unboxing, the loader felt lightweight and constructed of what appeared to be durable polymer. The loading arm seemed sturdy enough to handle the repetitive motion. Initially, I was cautiously optimistic, hoping it wouldn’t feel flimsy during actual use.

I considered other magazine loaders like the Maglula LULA, which is a popular and reliable option, and some generic universal loaders. I ultimately chose the Butler Creek ASAP because of its promise of speed and its compatibility with both loose ammo and stripper clips, offering versatility that some of the others lacked. The price point of $22.99 also made it an appealing option.

My first impression was a mix of curiosity and slight apprehension. Would it live up to the hype, or would it be another gadget that ends up gathering dust in my range bag? I was excited to put it to the test and see if it truly delivered on its claims of speed and ease of use.

Real-World Testing: Putting Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish to the Test

First Use Experience

I tested the Butler Creek ASAP at an outdoor shooting range on a brisk fall day. The temperature was around 50 degrees Fahrenheit, and there was a slight wind, adding a bit of a chill to my hands. I brought several AR-15 magazines of varying brands and capacities to ensure compatibility.

The first few attempts were frustrating. The loader seemed to jam frequently, especially when trying to load more than a few rounds at a time. It would require me to pause, readjust the rounds, and then try again.

The initial learning curve was steeper than expected. I had anticipated a seamless loading experience, but instead, I found myself struggling to get the rounds to feed properly.

After some experimentation, I discovered that loading smaller batches of rounds – around five at a time – significantly improved the loader’s performance. A more forceful push was also needed to ensure the rounds properly seated in the magazine. This workaround mitigated the jamming issue somewhat, but it still wasn’t the rapid-fire loading experience I had hoped for.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several range trips and hundreds of rounds loaded, the Butler Creek ASAP has held up reasonably well, but with reservations. There are no visible signs of significant wear and tear on the polymer body. It continues to function, albeit with the same quirks I encountered initially.

Durability has been adequate, but I am somewhat concerned about the longevity of the loading arm, as it seems like a potential point of failure with repeated use.

Maintenance is simple; I just wipe it down with a cloth after each use to remove any dirt or debris. No special cleaning or lubrication is required.

Compared to manually loading magazines, the Butler Creek ASAP is marginally faster once you get the hang of it, but not by a significant margin. It does reduce hand fatigue to some extent, but the need to load in smaller batches negates some of the time savings. It definitely did not outperform my expectations, and at times was more frustrating than simply loading by hand.

Breaking Down the Features of Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish

Specifications

  • The Butler Creek ASAP is designed for .223 Remington caliber ammunition, making it specifically suited for AR-15/M-16 platforms. This is a key selling point for AR owners.

  • The loader has a black finish and is constructed from a durable polymer material, contributing to its lightweight design. The polymer construction makes it rugged enough for range use.

  • It’s advertised to handle up to 10 rounds of loose ammo or ammo in a stripper clip, offering versatility in how you load your magazines. The ability to use both loose rounds and stripper clips is a nice feature, though its performance with the former can be inconsistent.

  • The model is simply designated as “ASAP,” reflecting its intended purpose of rapid magazine loading. The name emphasizes the primary function of the loader.

  • The price is listed at $22.99, making it an affordable option for shooters looking to simplify the magazine loading process. The relatively low cost makes it an attractive entry point for many.

Performance & Functionality

The Butler Creek ASAP loader’s primary function is to speed up the magazine loading process, and it does so to a degree. However, the performance isn’t as seamless as advertised. The loader is more effective with smaller batches of rounds, which mitigates some of the intended time savings.

The loader’s biggest weakness is its tendency to jam, particularly when attempting to load larger quantities of rounds. The need for a forceful push to seat the rounds properly can also be tiring after loading several magazines.

The loader met some expectations in terms of reducing hand fatigue, but fell short of providing a significant speed advantage over manual loading. The user feedback mentioning the necessity of loading five rounds at a time aligns with my own experience.

Design & Ergonomics

The Butler Creek ASAP loader is designed to be lightweight and compact, making it easy to carry in a range bag. The polymer construction feels durable enough for regular use, though its long-term robustness remains to be seen.

Ergonomically, the loader is relatively simple to use, but the learning curve and the need for a specific technique reduce its user-friendliness. The need for a forceful push might be challenging for some users.

Durability & Maintenance

The Butler Creek ASAP seems reasonably durable for its intended purpose, but the polymer construction might not withstand extreme conditions or heavy use. The loading arm appears to be the most vulnerable component.

Maintenance is straightforward: simply wipe down the loader after each use to remove any dirt or debris. No special cleaning or lubrication is required.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish doesn’t come with any accessories. There are no customization options available for this product. Its functionality is self-contained and doesn’t rely on external components. However, it is compatible with standard AR-15/M-16 magazines.

Pros and Cons of Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish

Pros

  • Reduces hand fatigue compared to manual loading.
  • Compatible with both loose ammo and stripper clips.
  • Lightweight and compact design.
  • Affordable price point.
  • Simple maintenance.

Cons

  • Tends to jam, especially when loading larger quantities of rounds.
  • Requires a specific technique and forceful push for optimal performance.
  • Not significantly faster than manual loading.


Who Should Buy Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish?

The Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish is perfect for casual shooters who experience hand fatigue when loading magazines or those who primarily use stripper clips. It can also benefit shooters on a budget who want an affordable loading solution.

Those who prioritize speed and efficiency or frequently load large quantities of magazines should skip this product. Shooters looking for a highly reliable and jam-free loading experience would also be better served by alternative options.

A must-have modification isn’t necessarily applicable, but users should be sure to have good quality magazines. Also, having some experience with magazine loaders in general will help mitigate the initial learning curve.

Conclusion on Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish

The Butler Creek ASAP AR-15/M-16 Magazine Loader Black Finish offers a mixed bag of performance. While it does reduce hand fatigue and provides some convenience, it falls short of delivering the rapid and seamless loading experience it promises.

The value proposition is decent, given its affordable price, but the jamming issues and need for a specific technique detract from its overall usability.

Personally, I would recommend the Butler Creek ASAP with reservations. It’s a decent entry-level option for casual shooters, but serious shooters or those who prioritize speed and reliability should consider investing in a higher-quality magazine loader. If you are on a tight budget and willing to invest the time to learn its quirks, then the Butler Creek ASAP might be worth a try.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top