Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish Review

First Thoughts on the Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish

The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish promises a faster and easier way to load double-stack pistol magazines. Butler Creek, a well-known name in firearm accessories, aims to solve the age-old problem of sore thumbs and tedious magazine loading. Is this a game-changer, or just another plastic gadget destined for the range bag graveyard?

Magazine loading, especially after a long day of training or competition, can be a real pain. My thumbs often feel raw, and the process significantly cuts into valuable range time. So, I was looking for a simple, reliable loader that could handle a variety of my double-stack magazines, from my Glock 19 to my 1911.

Upon unboxing, the ASAP loader feels lightweight, almost too lightweight. The black plastic construction doesn’t exactly scream “high-end,” but for the price, I wasn’t expecting titanium. My initial impression was cautiously optimistic; it seemed straightforward enough, but I reserved judgment until I could put it through its paces.

I considered other loaders like the Maglula UpLULA and ETS CAM Loader. Ultimately, the price point of the Butler Creek loader was a significant factor, especially as a potential entry-level option. I wanted to see if a budget-friendly loader could deliver on its promises without breaking the bank. My initial excitement was tempered by a healthy dose of skepticism, hoping it would exceed my expectations, but prepared for a potential letdown.

Real-World Testing: Putting Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish to the Test

First Use Experience

I tested the Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish at my local outdoor shooting range. The weather was dry and sunny, perfect conditions for shooting, but a good test of whether the loader would slip due to sweaty hands. I brought a variety of magazines, including Glock 19 (9mm), Sig Sauer P226 (9mm), and a 1911 (.45 ACP) magazine.

The initial loading experience was a mixed bag. It took a few tries to get the hang of aligning the loader correctly and applying consistent pressure. I noticed some magazines loaded smoothly, while others required more effort and a slower, more deliberate motion.

I did experience a couple of instances where rounds didn’t seat properly in the magazine, requiring me to manually push them in. This slowed down the loading process, negating some of the intended speed benefits.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of use, the Butler Creek loader shows no significant signs of wear and tear. The plastic, while not premium, seems durable enough for its intended purpose. Cleaning is simple, just wiping it down with a damp cloth to remove any dirt or debris.

Compared to manually loading magazines, the Butler Creek offers a marginal improvement in speed for some magazines. It’s a far cry from the effortless loading experience promised by more expensive loaders. My thumbs still get a workout, just a slightly less intense one.

Breaking Down the Features of Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish

Specifications

The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish is designed for multi-caliber use, specifically targeting double-stack magazines between .380 ACP and .45 ACP. Its black finish gives it a utilitarian look. The model is designated as “ASAP,” suggesting a focus on speed and convenience.

The ASAP loader weighs practically nothing, thanks to its plastic construction, making it easy to carry in a range bag or pocket. This multi-caliber capability aims to simplify the loading process for shooters with diverse pistol platforms.

Performance & Functionality

The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish performs adequately, but not exceptionally. It does load magazines, but not with the speed and ease I was hoping for. The “ASAP” moniker feels a bit misleading.

Its strength lies in its ability to load a variety of double-stack magazines, however, its weakness is the inconsistent loading experience. Some magazines load smoothly, while others require more finesse. It meets basic expectations, but doesn’t exceed them.

Design & Ergonomics

The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish is made of black plastic, which feels functional but not particularly premium. Its lightweight design makes it easy to handle, but doesn’t inspire confidence in its durability. The ergonomics are decent, although the handle could benefit from a more textured surface for better grip.

There is a slight learning curve involved in mastering the proper technique, requiring some practice to achieve optimal performance.

Durability & Maintenance

The plastic construction of the Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish raises some concerns about long-term durability. It seems likely to withstand regular use, but may not hold up to rough handling or extreme conditions. Maintenance is straightforward; simply wipe it clean as needed.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish doesn’t come with any accessories. Customization options are non-existent. It is a simple, standalone tool with no provisions for modification.

Pros and Cons of Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish

Pros

  • Affordable price point.
  • Multi-caliber compatibility (.380 ACP – .45 ACP).
  • Lightweight and portable.
  • Simple design, easy to understand.
  • Offers some relief for sore thumbs compared to manual loading.

Cons

  • Inconsistent loading performance.
  • Feels flimsy and cheap.
  • Requires practice to master the technique.
  • Not significantly faster than manual loading for all magazines.


Who Should Buy Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish?

The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish is perfect for budget-conscious shooters looking for a basic magazine loader. It’s also suitable for those who own a variety of double-stack pistols and want a single tool to load them all. This is a great tool for new shooters who struggle with magazine loading.

If you’re looking for a high-speed, premium loader, or prioritize durability, skip this product. Must-have modifications? None. Its simple design doesn’t lend itself to customization.

Conclusion on Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish

The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish offers a budget-friendly solution to the age-old problem of magazine loading. It doesn’t revolutionize the process, but it does provide a marginal improvement over manual loading, especially for certain magazines. The Butler Creek loader is not a game changer, but can be a useful tool for the budget-conscious shooter.

Its low price is justified, but don’t expect premium performance. I would recommend it with reservations. If you’re on a tight budget and want a simple loader for occasional use, the Butler Creek loader is worth considering. If you are serious about saving time and effort, invest in a higher-quality option.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top