Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo Review

First Impressions of Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo

The Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo presents itself as a compact, all-in-one solution for those needing a folding knife and sharpening capabilities in a readily accessible package. As someone who’s spent over a decade field-testing gear, I’m always skeptical of “combo” products, often finding they compromise quality in one area to offer convenience. This review will thoroughly dissect whether the EdgeSport Combo breaks that mold or falls into the trap of being a jack-of-all-trades, master of none.

My need for a reliable, portable sharpening solution often arises during extended backcountry trips where maintaining a keen edge on my primary knife is paramount for tasks ranging from game processing to shelter building. The promise of having a functional blade paired with a sharpener immediately piqued my interest.

Upon unboxing, the first thing that struck me was its lightweight design. The black textured synthetic handle felt surprisingly grippy, even with damp hands, though the overall build felt more utilitarian than premium. It includes a two-stage sharpener integrated into the handle itself. Initial impressions leaned towards cautious optimism, questioning whether such a compact sharpener could genuinely restore a dulled blade effectively.

Compared to carrying a dedicated, high-end folding knife like a Benchmade Bugout and a separate sharpening stone, the EdgeSport Combo offered undeniable space and weight savings. I considered alternatives like the Lansky Roadie, a keychain sharpener, but the EdgeSport Combo’s integrated knife provided a complete package. Ultimately, the Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo was chosen for its potential for convenience and portability, hoping to prove that a combo tool can still hold its own. I was cautiously excited, keen to see if its performance matched its convenience.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo to the Test

First Use Experience

I took the Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo on a week-long backpacking trip in the unforgiving terrain of the Appalachian Trail. My primary tasks included preparing food, feathering sticks for fire starting, and making minor gear repairs. The knife performed adequately for these tasks, though the 3-inch blade felt somewhat limiting compared to my usual 4-inch blade.

The weather was a mixed bag, with periods of heavy rain and humidity. The textured synthetic handle provided a secure grip even when wet. The sharpener was used to touch up the blade after a couple of days of use. Initial attempts were promising, and the carbide side was effective at quickly restoring a dull edge, but it felt somewhat aggressive.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of regular use, the Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo demonstrated acceptable durability, but some areas of concern emerged. The blade’s 420 stainless steel showed some minor scratches and surface rust spots after being exposed to moisture. The sharpening portion still works, but the ceramic rods have started to come loose.

The knife required frequent cleaning, especially after processing food, to prevent corrosion. The sharpener itself accumulated debris and required regular cleaning with a small brush. Compared to my usual maintenance routine for higher-end blades using oil and strop, the EdgeSport Combo demanded a little more vigilance to prevent degradation. While convenient, its performance fell short of higher-end, dedicated tools in both blade quality and sharpening effectiveness.

Breaking Down the Features of Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo

Specifications

• The Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo features a 4-inch closed length making it compact for easy carry. This is a major advantage for those prioritizing space and weight.
• The 3-inch satin finish 420 stainless steel blade offers decent corrosion resistance and edge retention for basic tasks. However, 420 stainless steel is generally considered a lower-end steel compared to options like AUS-8 or S30V.
• The black textured synthetic handle provides a secure grip, even in wet conditions. This ensures safe and confident handling.
• The integrated two-stage sharpener features both carbide and ceramic blades. This allows for both quick edge restoration and fine honing.
• The inclusion of non-slip feet on the sharpener provides stability during use. The lanyard hole allows for convenient attachment to a backpack or keychain.
• Weighing in at just 0.38 lbs, this combo is extremely lightweight. This will reduce carry fatigue.

Performance & Functionality

The Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo performs adequately for light to medium-duty tasks. The blade is sharp enough for most everyday cutting needs. However, it struggles with more demanding tasks like batoning wood or heavy prying.

The integrated sharpener is a convenient feature, but it’s not a replacement for a dedicated sharpening system. The carbide side aggressively restores a dull edge but can also remove too much material if not used carefully. The ceramic side provides a finer edge but requires more patience and skill to achieve optimal results. It meets the basic expectations of an all-in-one tool but doesn’t excel in either knife quality or sharpening prowess.

Design & Ergonomics

The EdgeSport Combo’s design prioritizes portability and convenience over premium aesthetics. The synthetic handle, while functional, lacks the refined feel of G10 or Micarta. The knife feels relatively lightweight in hand, which is a plus for extended carry.

The sharpener is cleverly integrated into the handle, but this design compromises the overall ergonomics of the knife. The handle feels slightly bulky and less comfortable than a standard folding knife handle. It has a noticeable learning curve.

Durability & Maintenance

The 420 stainless steel blade is susceptible to corrosion if not properly maintained. Regular cleaning and lubrication are essential, especially in humid environments. The sharpener’s carbide and ceramic blades are also prone to wear and tear with frequent use.

Replacing the sharpening components isn’t straightforward. This makes the EdgeSport Combo more of a disposable tool than a long-term investment.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo comes with no additional accessories beyond what is integrated into the tool itself. There are no customization options available. The blade cannot be swapped, and the handle scales are not designed to be replaced.

The lack of customization limits the EdgeSport Combo’s appeal to serious outdoor enthusiasts who prefer to fine-tune their gear to specific needs. It’s a standalone package designed for basic functionality.

Pros and Cons of Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo

Check Best Price HERE

Who Should Buy Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo?

The Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo is perfect for casual campers, beginner hikers, and anyone looking for an inexpensive, all-in-one knife and sharpening solution for light-duty tasks. It’s also a decent option for a backup knife in a survival kit, where space and weight are critical considerations.

Experienced outdoorsmen, professional guides, and anyone who demands high performance from their cutting tools should skip this product. They’d be better served by investing in a higher-quality knife and a dedicated sharpening system. Must-have accessories would be a rust inhibitor oil and a small cleaning brush to maintain the blade and sharpener.

Conclusion on Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo

The Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo offers a compelling blend of convenience and affordability, though with some caveats. The integrated sharpener is a clever idea, providing a readily accessible way to maintain a functional edge in the field. However, the compromise in blade steel quality and handle ergonomics limits its appeal to serious users.

At $33.99, the price is justified for what it offers, but understand that you’re paying for convenience over top-tier performance. I would personally recommend it as a budget-friendly option for casual users who prioritize portability and ease of use. It’s not a replacement for a high-quality knife and sharpening system. Its a decent choice if you know you will use the sharpener. If not, buy a higher-end knife. Ultimately, the Smith’s Sharpeners EdgeSport Combo is a testament to the fact that while combo tools can be convenient, true performance often comes from dedicated, purpose-built gear. If you’re looking for a do-it-all solution on a budget, this might fit the bill – but remember to temper your expectations accordingly.