Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife Review

Let’s Talk About Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife

The Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife is a classic design, hearkening back to the iconic Sykes-Fairbairn fighting knife. Manufactured by Sheffield, this dagger aims to provide a reliable and historically inspired tool for collectors and users alike. The 6.875-inch stainless steel blade and black leather sheath contribute to its classic aesthetic and functional design.

I was in the market for a traditional-style dagger for my historical knife collection, and the Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife caught my eye. I needed a blade that not only looked the part but also felt solid and well-constructed.

Upon unboxing, the knife felt surprisingly hefty, giving a sense of durability. The stainless steel handle, coated in black, provides a solid grip, while the blade’s black finish adds to its tactical appearance. My initial impression was that this knife offered good value for the price, though I was slightly concerned about the sheath’s long-term durability.

Compared to similar daggers like the Gerber Mark II or a reproduction Sykes-Fairbairn, the Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife offered a more budget-friendly option without sacrificing too much in terms of build quality. Ultimately, I chose this knife for its balance of price, historical design, and overall solid feel.

I was cautiously optimistic. The dagger looked the part, but the real test would be how it felt in hand and how well it held up with use.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife to the Test

First Use Experience

I first tested the Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife during a weekend camping trip in the Appalachian Mountains. I used it primarily for basic camp tasks like cutting rope, preparing kindling, and practicing knife throwing at a soft target.

The knife performed adequately in dry conditions. However, the stainless steel handle became slippery when wet, making it difficult to maintain a secure grip. I didn’t expect to use it in combat, but I immediately noticed that any tactical application would be hindered by the lack of a textured grip.

The dagger was relatively easy to handle, though the double-edged blade took some getting used to. My main issue after the first use was the sheath’s retention, which felt loose and insecure.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several months of occasional use, the Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife has held up fairly well. There are some minor scratches on the blade’s black finish, but no significant signs of wear or damage.

The blade has maintained its edge reasonably well, though I’ve had to sharpen it a few times to keep it in optimal condition. The leather sheath, however, has shown signs of wear and tear, with the stitching starting to fray.

Compared to my experience with higher-end daggers, the Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife performs adequately for light tasks and collection purposes. However, it lacks the refined balance and superior edge retention of more expensive models. Its reliability is acceptable for its price point, but it’s not a heavy-duty tool I’d rely on in demanding situations.

Breaking Down the Features of Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife

Specifications

• Overall Length: 11.875 inches. This provides a substantial feel in the hand and adequate reach for various tasks.

• Blade Length: 6.875 inches with a Standard Edge. This blade length is suitable for both utility and self-defense scenarios.

• Blade Material: Stainless Steel. It offers decent corrosion resistance, but may not hold an edge as well as higher-carbon steels.

• Handle Material: Stainless Steel with a Black Finish. The all-metal construction adds to the knife’s durability but might compromise grip in wet conditions.

• Sheath Material: Leather. It provides a classic look but may require more maintenance than synthetic sheaths.

• Sykes Fairbairn Pattern: The design pays homage to a classic fighting knife. It is intended for thrusting and piercing rather than slicing.

These specifications are significant because they influence the knife’s performance and intended use. The stainless steel blade and handle prioritize durability, while the Sykes Fairbairn pattern dictates its primary function as a piercing weapon.

Performance & Functionality

The Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife performs reasonably well for its intended purpose. It’s a decent thrusting weapon and can handle light utility tasks.

The knife’s strengths lie in its classic design and solid feel. However, its weaknesses include a slippery handle, a somewhat dull factory edge, and a subpar sheath.

It meets basic expectations for a budget-friendly dagger, but it doesn’t exceed them in terms of performance or overall quality. It would benefit from improved grip and a better factory edge.

Design & Ergonomics

The build quality is decent, with a solid all-metal construction. However, the black coating on the stainless steel handle doesn’t provide much grip.

The knife has a classic, utilitarian design. While it looks the part, the lack of ergonomic features detracts from its overall user-friendliness.

Durability & Maintenance

The stainless steel construction suggests reasonable durability. The blade’s black finish, however, is prone to scratching.

The knife is easy to clean and maintain, requiring only occasional sharpening and oiling. The leather sheath, however, needs regular conditioning to prevent cracking and drying.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife comes with a basic black leather belt sheath. There are limited customization options available, as the handle is not designed for easy replacement.

The knife is compatible with some generic aftermarket sheaths designed for similar-sized daggers. However, there are no official accessories or customization options offered by Sheffield. Aftermarket handle wraps may be added for additional grip.

Pros and Cons of Sheffield Commando Dagger Fixed Blade Knife