Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife Review

First Impressions of Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife

The Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife is a classic pocketknife, a piece of Americana that harkens back to simpler times. Manufactured by Old Timer, a brand synonymous with quality and tradition, this knife boasts a timeless design and practical functionality, making it a compelling option for everyday carry. What immediately catches the eye is its Heritage Series aesthetic, featuring wood laminate scales and nickel silver bolsters, elements that speak to its old-school charm.

I was searching for a reliable, compact, and traditional pocketknife for everyday tasks and light outdoor use. Modern tactical folders are great, but sometimes a classic slipjoint is all you need, and it’s far more socially acceptable. The Old Timer 34OTH seemed like a perfect fit, offering a blend of functionality and vintage appeal.

Upon unboxing, the Old Timer 34OTH feels solid and well-made for its price point. The wood laminate handles provide a comfortable grip, and the three blades (Clip Point, Sheepsfoot, and Spey) are functional and versatile. The overall build quality appears to be robust, and the knife has a satisfying weight in hand.

Compared to similar knives like the Case Trapper or the Buck 301 Stockman, the Old Timer 34OTH stood out due to its D2 steel blades at its price point. Many traditional knives at this price point use less desirable steel. I also appreciated the classic look and feel of the Old Timer brand, something that’s harder to find in modern, mass-produced knives.

My initial impression was positive; the Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife exceeded my expectations. I was pleasantly surprised by the fit and finish, and I looked forward to putting it through its paces in real-world scenarios.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife to the Test

First Use Experience

I first tested the Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife during a weekend camping trip in the Appalachian Mountains. I used it for a variety of tasks, including food preparation, cutting rope, whittling, and general camp chores. The knife performed admirably in dry conditions and proved to be a handy tool around the campsite.

The multiple blades proved useful for different tasks. The clip point was great for detail work, the sheepsfoot for slicing, and the spey blade for tasks where a duller edge was preferred. The knife was easy to use right out of the box, with no break-in period required for smooth opening and closing.

The only minor issue I encountered was a slight stiffness in opening the blades initially, but that resolved itself after a bit of use. I was impressed by how well the Old Timer 34OTH handled the various tasks I threw at it during that first outing.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several months of regular use, the Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife has held up remarkably well. There are some minor scratches on the bolsters and handles, but this is to be expected with regular use and adds to the character of the knife. The D2 steel blades are showing no signs of chipping or excessive wear, even after repeated use.

The knife has proven to be very durable and reliable, a testament to its quality construction. It’s been used for everything from opening packages and cutting zip ties to preparing food and working on outdoor projects. Maintaining the Old Timer 34OTH is simple; I clean the blades after each use and occasionally apply a drop of oil to the joints.

Compared to some other pocketknives I’ve owned, the Old Timer 34OTH has outperformed them in terms of edge retention and overall durability. The D2 steel blades hold an edge exceptionally well, and the knife’s sturdy construction gives me confidence that it will last for many years. It doesn’t have the refinement of some higher-end slipjoints, but it’s an excellent value.

Breaking Down the Features of Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife

Specifications

• The Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife features a classic three-blade design: a Clip Point blade, a Sheepsfoot blade, and a Spey blade. This variety allows for versatile use in different scenarios.
• The blade material is D2 steel, a high-carbon, high-chromium tool steel known for its excellent edge retention and wear resistance. This is a significant upgrade from many other traditional knives in this price range.
• The blade length of the main blade is 2 inches, making it compact and easy to carry. The other two blades are slightly shorter, at 2.40″ and 1.70″.
• The handle material is wood laminate, providing a comfortable and secure grip. The wood laminate adds to the knife’s classic aesthetic.
• The knife features nickel silver bolsters, adding to its durability and visual appeal. The bolsters provide added strength and a touch of elegance.
• The Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife includes a nail nick on each blade for easy opening. This is a standard feature on traditional slipjoint knives.

These specifications are important because they directly impact the knife’s performance and usability. The D2 steel ensures that the blades stay sharp for longer, while the wood laminate handles provide a comfortable and secure grip. The three-blade design offers versatility, making it suitable for a wide range of tasks.

Performance & Functionality

The Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife performs its job exceptionally well. The D2 steel blades are incredibly sharp and hold an edge for an extended period, requiring less frequent sharpening. The three distinct blade shapes each excel at different tasks, making this a versatile tool for everyday carry and outdoor use.

One of the strengths of the Old Timer 34OTH is its versatility. The clip point blade is ideal for detailed cutting and piercing, the sheepsfoot blade is perfect for slicing and whittling, and the spey blade is useful for tasks where a duller edge is preferred. A weakness is the lack of a locking mechanism, but this is typical of traditional slipjoint knives.

The knife meets and, in some aspects, exceeds expectations. The D2 steel blade and overall build quality are impressive for a knife in this price range. It provides excellent value for those looking for a reliable and versatile pocketknife.

Design & Ergonomics

The Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife boasts a classic and timeless design. The wood laminate handles and nickel silver bolsters give it a traditional look and feel. The weight is well-balanced, making it comfortable to hold and use for extended periods.

The knife is user-friendly with no significant learning curve. The nail nicks on each blade make them easy to open, and the slipjoint mechanism provides smooth and reliable operation. The handle design is comfortable and ergonomic, even for larger hands.

Durability & Maintenance

The Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife is built to last. The D2 steel blades are highly resistant to wear and corrosion, and the wood laminate handles are durable and long-lasting. With proper care and maintenance, this knife should provide years of reliable service.

Maintaining the Old Timer 34OTH is simple. Regular cleaning and occasional oiling of the joints are all that’s required to keep it in top condition. The knife is also relatively easy to sharpen, although D2 steel can be more challenging to sharpen than some other steels.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife does not come with any specific accessories. However, it is compatible with standard knife sharpening tools and maintenance products. Customization options are limited due to the traditional design, but aftermarket sheaths are available.

There are no readily available aftermarket grips or blades for this knife. The focus is on preserving its classic design.

Pros and Cons of Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife

Check Best Price HERE

Who Should Buy Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife?

The Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife is perfect for:

• Everyday Carry (EDC) Users: Those who appreciate a classic, reliable, and versatile pocketknife for everyday tasks.
• Hunters and Anglers: A useful tool for field dressing game, cutting line, and other outdoor tasks.
• Campers and Hikers: A compact and lightweight knife for general camp chores and outdoor adventures.
• Collectors of Traditional Knives: A valuable addition to any collection of classic pocketknives.

Who should skip this product? Those who require a locking blade for safety or prefer a more modern, tactical design. Those looking for extensive customization options should also consider other alternatives.

Must-have accessories or modifications? A quality knife sharpening stone or system is recommended to maintain the D2 steel blades. Also, a leather or nylon sheath can provide added protection and convenience for carrying.

Conclusion on Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife

The Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife is a fantastic blend of classic design and modern performance. The use of D2 steel for the blades is a significant upgrade that sets it apart from many other traditional pocketknives in its price range. While it may lack some of the features found on more modern knives, its simplicity, durability, and versatility make it an excellent choice for everyday carry and outdoor use.

The price is definitely justified, considering the quality of the materials and construction. You’re getting a lot of knife for your money.

I would absolutely recommend the Old Timer 34OTH Heritage Middleman Folding Knife to anyone looking for a reliable, versatile, and classic pocketknife. Whether you’re a seasoned outdoorsman or simply someone who appreciates a well-made tool, this knife is sure to impress. Pick one up today and experience the timeless appeal of an Old Timer!