Cold Steel Cinquedea Review

Let’s Dive into Cold Steel Cinquedea

The Cold Steel Cinquedea is a fascinating piece, a modern interpretation of a blade steeped in Italian Renaissance history. Marketed by Cold Steel as a civilian self-defense weapon that was a precursor to the rapier, it certainly holds a unique appeal. The Cinquedea’s wide, stiff blade and ornately engraved details are captivating.

My interest in the Cold Steel Cinquedea stems from a lifelong fascination with historical weaponry and a desire to own functional art. I was specifically looking for a blade that blended historical aesthetics with modern manufacturing techniques and materials to create a functional piece suitable for display and occasional use. The Cinquedea caught my eye because it appeared to achieve that balance.

Upon unboxing, the Cinquedea immediately impressed me with its size and heft. The 1055 carbon steel blade felt substantial, and the hand-carved rosewood grip offered a comfortable, secure hold. The engraved guard and pommel added a touch of elegance, while the included leather scabbard with engraved steel fittings provided a convenient and historically inspired carrying option. The build quality seemed solid.

Compared to other similar historical replicas I’ve handled, such as the Windlass Steelcrafts Medieval Dagger and the Hanwei Practical Dagger, the Cold Steel Cinquedea stands out due to its imposing size and the attention to detail in its embellishments. While the Windlass dagger focused on historical accuracy and the Hanwei on practicality, the Cinquedea seemed to strive for a blend of both. I chose the Cinquedea over these alternatives because I preferred its unique design and perceived value for money.

My initial impression was one of excitement. The Cold Steel Cinquedea appeared to be a well-made, visually appealing, and functional piece of historical weaponry, and I was eager to put it to the test.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting Cold Steel Cinquedea to the Test

First Use Experience

I first tested the Cold Steel Cinquedea in my backyard, focusing on handling, balance, and edge retention. The weather was dry and mild, providing optimal conditions for initial assessment. I practiced basic cutting and thrusting motions against cardboard boxes and wooden targets to evaluate its performance.

In dry conditions, the Cinquedea’s rosewood grip provided a secure and comfortable hold, even with prolonged use. The blade felt well-balanced, allowing for relatively quick and precise movements despite its size. The wide blade cut through cardboard with ease and penetrated wooden targets effectively, showcasing its potential as a thrusting weapon.

The Cinquedea did require some time to get used to, primarily due to its unique shape and size. The short handle and wide blade demanded a different grip and technique than a traditional knife or sword, but after a few hours of practice, I felt more confident in my ability to wield it effectively.

After the initial testing, I did notice that the edge wasn’t as sharp as I expected out of the box, which was surprising. It wasn’t dull, but it would definitely benefit from some sharpening before practical use.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of use, the Cold Steel Cinquedea has held up reasonably well. I’ve used it for light yard work (cutting small branches) and continued practicing with it on targets.

The blade has retained its shape and integrity, with no signs of bending or warping. However, the satin finish has shown some minor scratches and scuffs from repeated use. The leather scabbard has also started to show some wear, particularly around the throat and chape.

Maintenance is relatively straightforward: I clean the blade with a dry cloth after each use and apply a thin coat of oil to prevent rust. The rosewood grip requires occasional cleaning with a damp cloth and a mild wood cleaner. Overall, the Cinquedea is relatively easy to maintain.

Compared to other blades I’ve owned, the Cold Steel Cinquedea is both more impressive and more limited in its application. Its historical design and imposing size make it a conversation starter and a visually striking piece.

Breaking Down the Features of Cold Steel Cinquedea

Specifications

The Cold Steel Cinquedea boasts the following specifications:

• Blade Length: 14.5 inches, providing a substantial cutting and thrusting surface.
• Overall Length: 20.5 inches, making it a relatively compact weapon for its type.
• Blade Shape: Dagger, designed for both cutting and thrusting attacks.
• Blade Material: 1060 Carbon Steel, offering a good balance of hardness and toughness. Note that the product details list 1055 carbon steel, yet the specifications table lists 1060. It is likely 1055, as that is Cold Steel’s standard for weapons of this type.
• Handle Material: Rosewood, offering a comfortable and aesthetically pleasing grip.
• Weight: 28.7 oz, giving it a substantial feel in the hand.
• The blade is 0.125 inches thick, providing strength for thrusting.

These specifications matter because they directly impact the Cinquedea’s performance and handling. The blade length determines its reach and cutting power, while the blade material dictates its durability and edge retention. The weight affects its maneuverability and ease of use, and the handle material influences its comfort and grip.

Performance & Functionality

The Cold Steel Cinquedea performs its intended job reasonably well. The blade’s shape and sharpness allow for effective cutting and thrusting. The handle provides a secure grip, enabling precise control.

The Cinquedea’s strengths lie in its historical design, impressive size, and relatively good balance. However, its edge retention could be improved. The factory edge is adequate, but not exceptional.

The Cold Steel Cinquedea meets expectations for a decorative yet functional replica. While it may not be suitable for heavy-duty tasks, it is perfectly capable of light cutting and thrusting and serves as a visually appealing addition to any collection.

Design & Ergonomics

The Cold Steel Cinquedea features a visually striking design inspired by historical Italian weaponry. The hand-carved rosewood grip is comfortable and provides a secure hold. The engraved guard and pommel add a touch of elegance.

The build quality is generally good, with solid construction and durable materials. However, the fit and finish could be improved in some areas.

The Cinquedea is reasonably user-friendly, though it does require some practice to master its unique handling characteristics. The short handle and wide blade demand a specific grip and technique.

Durability & Maintenance

With proper care, the Cold Steel Cinquedea should last for many years. The 1055 carbon steel blade is durable and resistant to bending or warping.

Maintenance is relatively simple: clean and oil the blade regularly to prevent rust, and occasionally clean the rosewood grip with a damp cloth.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Cold Steel Cinquedea comes with a leather scabbard with engraved steel fittings. No other accessories are included.

Customization options are limited, as the Cinquedea is primarily intended as a decorative piece. However, the rosewood grip could potentially be replaced with a custom-made handle, or the blade could be re-profiled to improve its cutting performance. The steel guard and pommel could be further engraved or plated.

Pros and Cons of Cold Steel Cinquedea