Coghlans Hinged Broiler Review

The Coghlans Hinged Broiler Made a Bold First Impression

The Coghlans Hinged Broiler immediately strikes you as a simple, yet potentially invaluable, tool for outdoor cooking. This chrome-plated grill, designed for grilling everything from burgers to fish over an open flame, promised a level of convenience that piqued my interest. I was tired of balancing food precariously on makeshift grilling surfaces during camping trips, and the Coghlans Hinged Broiler seemed like a solution.

For years, I’ve been improvising cooking setups on the trail. Flat rocks, carefully arranged foil, or even just roasting sticks have been the norm, but they’re often messy, uneven, and sometimes unsafe. I wanted a lightweight, portable solution that would let me cook directly over the fire without the hassle.

Upon unboxing, the Coghlans Hinged Broiler felt surprisingly sturdy for its $8.99 price tag. The chrome plating looked clean, and the hinged design with its locking ring seemed secure enough to hold food in place. Its lightweight nature was also immediately appealing, suggesting it wouldn’t add significant bulk to my pack.

I considered a couple of other options before settling on the Coghlans Hinged Broiler. There were some foldable, stainless-steel grill grates available, but they were bulkier and considerably more expensive. I also looked at some dedicated camping grills, but they were far too heavy and specialized for my general-purpose needs. I chose the Coghlans Hinged Broiler because of its simplicity, price, and promise of portability.

My first impression was one of cautious optimism. The design seemed practical, and the price was certainly right, but I was eager to see how it would perform in a real-world setting. Would it hold up to the heat? Would the chrome plating prove durable? These were the questions I hoped to answer.

Real-World Testing: Putting Coghlans Hinged Broiler to the Test

First Use Experience

I first tested the Coghlans Hinged Broiler during a weekend camping trip in the Allegheny National Forest. It was a classic fall outing, with cool evenings and the promise of trout sizzling over a campfire. I planned to cook trout fillets and some basic campfire toast using this new tool.

The conditions were mostly dry, with a slight chill in the air as the sun went down. I set up a small fire ring and let the flames burn down to a bed of hot coals, perfect for grilling. The initial use was surprisingly easy. I placed the trout fillets inside the Coghlans Hinged Broiler, secured the locking ring, and placed it directly over the coals.

The Coghlans Hinged Broiler heated up quickly, and the trout began to sizzle almost immediately. The hinged design allowed me to flip the fillets easily, ensuring even cooking. There was a slight learning curve in judging the distance from the coals to prevent burning, but after a few minutes, I had perfectly cooked trout.

My main concern after the first use was the cleaning. The chrome plating showed signs of discoloration from the intense heat, and remnants of the fish were stubbornly clinging to the grill. It would require a bit more elbow grease than I initially anticipated.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of use during various camping and scouting trips, the Coghlans Hinged Broiler has held up reasonably well. I’ve used it to cook everything from hotdogs and hamburgers to thicker cuts of steak. It became an essential piece of my lightweight cooking kit.

The durability, however, is a bit of a mixed bag. The chrome plating is showing more signs of wear and tear, with some areas becoming significantly discolored and losing their shine. The locking ring, while still functional, has become slightly looser over time.

Maintenance requires a bit of effort. A wire brush and some elbow grease are necessary to remove burnt-on food residue. I’ve found that soaking the Coghlans Hinged Broiler in hot, soapy water helps loosen the grime, but it’s still not a completely effortless process.

Compared to previous improvised grilling methods, the Coghlans Hinged Broiler is a vast improvement in terms of convenience and cooking consistency. However, it doesn’t match the durability of dedicated stainless-steel grilling systems that I’ve used in the past. The trade-off, of course, is the price and portability.

Breaking Down the Features of Coghlans Hinged Broiler

Specifications

The Coghlans Hinged Broiler boasts a simple, functional design. The key specs include:

• Overall Length: 29 1/2 inches. The long handle provides safe distance from the heat source.
• Grill Surface: 8″ X 9″ X 1″. This size is adequate for cooking meals for 1-2 people.
• Material: Chrome-plated steel. This keeps the price point low.
• Design: Hinged with locking ring. This design allows easy flipping of food while keeping it secure.

These specifications matter because they dictate the broiler’s portability, ease of use, and suitability for various cooking scenarios. The long handle is critical for safety, preventing burns. The grill surface is large enough for a decent-sized meal, but small enough to remain lightweight.

Performance & Functionality

The Coghlans Hinged Broiler performs its primary function—grilling food over an open flame—reasonably well. It heats up quickly and provides even cooking when properly managed. The hinged design is genuinely useful for flipping food without needing additional utensils.

The main strength is its simplicity and ease of use. There’s no assembly required, and it’s ready to use straight out of the box. The weaknesses lie in its durability and cleaning requirements. The chrome plating is not as resilient as stainless steel and requires more maintenance.

It meets expectations for a budget-friendly grilling solution, but it doesn’t exceed them. It provides a convenient and effective way to cook over an open flame but doesn’t offer the long-lasting durability of higher-end options.

Design & Ergonomics

The design is straightforward and functional. The long handle provides a comfortable and safe grip. The hinged mechanism operates smoothly, and the locking ring secures the food effectively.

The build quality is acceptable for its price point. The chrome-plated steel is lightweight, but it doesn’t feel exceptionally robust. There’s a slight learning curve in mastering the cooking temperature, but overall, the design is user-friendly.

Durability & Maintenance

The Coghlans Hinged Broiler is not designed for heavy-duty use. With regular care, it should last for a few seasons of camping trips, but it’s not a long-term investment. The chrome plating is susceptible to rust and discoloration if not properly cleaned and stored.

Maintenance involves scrubbing with a wire brush after each use to remove food residue. Soaking in hot, soapy water can help loosen stubborn grime. Proper drying before storage is crucial to prevent rust.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Coghlans Hinged Broiler comes with no additional accessories. There are no customization options available. Its simplicity is part of its appeal, but it also means there’s limited room for modification.

It’s not compatible with any specific accessories from other brands, as it’s designed as a standalone grilling solution. However, any generic grilling tools, such as tongs or spatulas, can be used in conjunction with the broiler.

Pros and Cons of Coghlans Hinged Broiler

Check Best Price HERE

Who Should Buy Coghlans Hinged Broiler?

The Coghlans Hinged Broiler is perfect for casual campers, backpackers, and anyone looking for an affordable and portable grilling solution. It’s ideal for cooking simple meals over an open flame during short trips. It’s also a great option for scout troops or outdoor education programs on a budget.

This product is not ideal for those who prioritize durability and longevity. Serious grill masters, or those needing a grill for frequent and heavy use, should consider a more robust stainless-steel option. Anyone who dislikes thorough cleaning should also avoid this product.

A must-have accessory is a good quality wire brush for cleaning. Also, heat-resistant gloves are recommended for handling the broiler over hot coals.

Conclusion on Coghlans Hinged Broiler

The Coghlans Hinged Broiler is a surprisingly useful tool for anyone who enjoys cooking over an open flame. Its lightweight design and affordable price make it an excellent choice for casual campers and backpackers. While it doesn’t offer the same level of durability as more expensive options, it provides a convenient and effective way to grill food in the great outdoors.

The price is definitely justified, considering its portability and functionality. For under $10, you get a tool that significantly improves the campfire cooking experience.

I would personally recommend the Coghlans Hinged Broiler to anyone looking for a budget-friendly and portable grilling solution. It’s a simple, yet effective tool that makes cooking over a campfire much easier and more enjoyable. Grab one for your next camping trip and experience the joy of perfectly grilled food in the wilderness!

Check Best Price HERE