China Made McElroy Calvary Sword Review

First Impressions of China Made McElroy Calvary Sword

The China Made McElroy Calvary Sword. The name itself conjures images of daring cavalry charges and historical battles. But can a sword produced in China, at a price point of just $67.99, truly live up to the legacy of the McElroy name and the demanding role of a cavalry saber? This is the question that burned in my mind when I first laid eyes on this blade.

I needed a robust, full-tang blade for some upcoming outdoor survival skills demonstrations I would be doing for a local scout troop. Initially, I considered a traditional Bowie knife, but the theatrical potential of a saber was too enticing to ignore. Other swords in this price range felt flimsy and unreliable, often prioritizing aesthetics over functionality. The China Made McElroy Calvary Sword, despite its origin, seemed to offer a balance of affordability and practical design, based on the limited information available.

Upon unboxing, the sword felt surprisingly substantial. The weight, while not excessive, was noticeable and gave a sense of solid construction. The stainless-steel blade, at 30 inches, had a reasonable sheen, and the handle felt adequate in my grip. My initial impression was cautiously optimistic. This wasn’t a museum-quality replica, but it didn’t feel like a complete toy, either.

Compared to some decorative swords I’ve handled, which are essentially wall hangers, the China Made McElroy Calvary Sword felt more robust than those. Next to a high-end Cold Steel saber (three times the price), the difference in fit and finish was immediately apparent. Still, the McElroy held its own in terms of sheer size and potentially usable design, especially considering the price.

I was intrigued. The China Made McElroy Calvary Sword seemed to occupy a middle ground: not a high-end collector’s piece, but potentially a usable tool for specific outdoor applications. I wasn’t blown away, but I also wasn’t immediately disappointed. The real test would come in how it performed in the field.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting China Made McElroy Calvary Sword to the Test

First Use Experience

I took the China Made McElroy Calvary Sword to a heavily wooded area, a place I often use for testing survival gear. My initial goal was to assess its chopping ability on small branches and brush, simulating clearing a path or gathering firewood. The weather was dry, and the temperature was mild, ideal conditions for testing.

The blade’s performance was… adequate. It chopped through smaller branches (under 1 inch in diameter) with relative ease, but anything thicker required significant effort. Edge retention was acceptable for the first hour, but I noticed a dulling effect afterward. I also found the handle offered acceptable grip initially, but caused some discomfort after prolonged use, which led to less control.

After my first session, I noticed some minor loosening of the handle, and I was concerned about the sword’s long-term reliability.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of using the China Made McElroy Calvary Sword intermittently, my concerns about its durability proved valid. The handle became significantly looser, requiring tightening. Also, the blade developed several noticeable scratches and small nicks, despite only being used on relatively soft wood.

Maintaining the blade proved to be simple. A quick wipe down with oil after each use seemed to prevent rust. However, I had to regularly check and tighten the handle. Compared to my experiences with higher-quality blades, where maintenance is minimal, the China Made McElroy Calvary Sword demands more attention to prevent degradation.

It definitely falls short of what I expect from a serious outdoor tool.

Breaking Down the Features of China Made McElroy Calvary Sword

Specifications

The China Made McElroy Calvary Sword boasts the following specifications. Its blade length is listed at 30 inches, which feels accurate upon measurement. The blade material is stainless steel, which is a common choice for affordability, but less ideal for edge retention and durability compared to higher-carbon steels. The manufacturer is listed as China Made, offering little insight into the specific craftsmanship or quality control processes.

These specifications are important because they directly impact the sword’s performance. The stainless-steel blade is more resistant to rust than carbon steel, a plus for outdoor use, but it will require more frequent sharpening. The 30-inch blade length is typical for a cavalry saber, offering a decent balance between reach and maneuverability.

Performance & Functionality

The China Made McElroy Calvary Sword is functional. However, it’s far from exceptional. Its chopping ability is limited to smaller branches and light brush. It’s better suited for clearing light foliage than for heavy-duty cutting tasks. Edge retention is a major weakness, requiring frequent sharpening.

The sword’s strengths lie in its size and affordability. It offers a decent reach and has a certain theatrical appeal. However, its weaknesses, including poor edge retention and questionable durability, significantly limit its practical use. It meets the basic expectations of a sword-shaped object, but falls short of being a reliable tool.

Design & Ergonomics

The design of the China Made McElroy Calvary Sword is reminiscent of a classic cavalry saber. The build quality is where it falls short. The materials used feel inexpensive. The weight distribution is slightly blade-heavy, which can be tiring during extended use.

The handle is functional, but not particularly comfortable. There is a noticeable learning curve to effectively wielding the blade, particularly for those unfamiliar with saber techniques. The sword is not particularly user-friendly for complex tasks.

Durability & Maintenance

The China Made McElroy Calvary Sword‘s long-term durability is a major concern. After only a few weeks of use, the handle began to loosen, and the blade showed signs of wear and tear. It is difficult to predict how long the sword will last under regular use, but I expect it is not likely to survive rigorous conditions.

Maintenance is straightforward, requiring only cleaning and oiling. However, the loosening handle requires regular attention and may eventually necessitate more extensive repairs. The stainless-steel blade resists rust well.

Accessories and Customization Options

The China Made McElroy Calvary Sword does not come with any accessories. There are no obvious customization options. The design is fairly basic, with no readily apparent way to attach aftermarket grips or other enhancements.

The compatibility with accessories from other brands is essentially non-existent. The sword is a standalone product with limited potential for modification.

Pros and Cons of China Made McElroy Calvary Sword