The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish Made a Bold First Impression
The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish promises an affordable solution to a common problem: sore thumbs and tedious magazine loading. The Butler Creek name is synonymous with practical shooting accessories, so I was eager to see if this little loader lived up to the brand’s reputation. My search for a decent mag loader that wouldn’t break the bank led me to this particular product.
The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP comes in a simple blister pack, nothing fancy. The loader itself is lightweight, constructed of what appears to be fairly basic black plastic. I immediately noticed it felt less substantial than some of the more expensive, polymer-reinforced loaders I’ve used in the past. It immediately reminded me of the UpLULA universal loader, but a noticeably lighter and cheaper version. I picked the Butler Creek due to its affordability, hoping it could offer a reasonable loading experience for range days without requiring a significant investment. My initial thought was cautious optimism – could something so simple really make a difference?
Real-World Testing: Putting Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish to the Test
First Use Experience
I took the Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP to my local indoor shooting range. My standard testing arsenal included a Glock 19, a Sig Sauer P320, and a Springfield XD9, each with multiple magazines. The dry, controlled environment of the range presented ideal conditions for the initial test.
Loading the Glock magazines was relatively straightforward, though a bit slow. I experienced the user’s comment about it being “finicky” when rounds wouldn’t seat fully unless I went slowly. The Sig Sauer magazines presented a similar experience, requiring a deliberate pace to avoid misfeeds or jams within the loader itself. The Springfield XD9 magazines were the most problematic, often requiring extra force to push rounds past a certain point in the loading process. I definitely had to get used to its quirks.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several range sessions, the Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP is showing signs of wear, particularly around the feed lips. The plastic feels like it could eventually crack under sustained use. Cleaning is simple; a quick wipe-down with a cloth usually suffices. My previous experience with higher-end loaders suggests they offer much better long-term durability and speed, but for the price, the Butler Creek gets the job done, albeit slowly.
Breaking Down the Features of Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish
Specifications
- The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish is designed for use with double-stack pistol magazines. It is advertised to work with most double-stack magazines between .380 ACP and .45 ACP.
- The loader is constructed from black plastic. This helps keep the cost down, but does raise questions about long-term durability.
- The product weight is negligible, likely only a few ounces. This makes it easy to carry in a range bag.
- It features a universal design. This means it doesn’t require specific adaptors for different magazines.
- No specific magazine capacity is listed, as it simply facilitates loading. The loader works by pushing rounds down into the magazine, one at a time.
Performance & Functionality
The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP performs its basic function – loading magazines. It’s not particularly fast or efficient, but it does prevent sore thumbs. It falls short of expectations if you’re looking for rapid magazine loading, especially during a competition or training scenario.
Its primary weakness is its slow speed and occasional finickiness. The rounds don’t always seat perfectly unless you apply consistent, deliberate pressure. Its strength lies in its affordability; it’s a cheap solution for those who want to avoid thumb fatigue.
Design & Ergonomics
The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP design is simple and utilitarian. It’s lightweight and easy to hold, but the plastic feels cheap. There’s no learning curve, but the loading process isn’t particularly ergonomic compared to more sophisticated loaders.
Durability & Maintenance
Its durability is a major concern. The plastic construction feels like it could crack or break with heavy use. Maintenance is minimal; just keep it clean and free of debris.
Accessories and Customization Options
The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP does not come with any accessories. There are no customization options available. It’s a standalone product designed for a single purpose.
Pros and Cons of Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish
Pros
- Affordable price point.
- Works with a wide range of double-stack pistol magazines (.380 ACP – .45 ACP).
- Lightweight and portable.
- Simple to use with minimal learning curve.
- Reduces thumb fatigue during extended shooting sessions.
Cons
- Slow loading speed compared to more advanced loaders.
- Plastic construction raises durability concerns.
- Can be finicky; rounds may not seat properly without deliberate pressure.
Who Should Buy Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish?
This loader is perfect for casual shooters who occasionally visit the range and want a cheap way to ease magazine loading. It’s also suitable for beginners who are building their range gear on a budget. Individuals who should skip this product are competitive shooters, law enforcement personnel, or anyone who needs to load magazines quickly and efficiently.
A must-have accessory would be patience. You will need it when using the Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP.
Conclusion on Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish
The Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP Double Stack Pistol Magazine Loader Black Finish offers a budget-friendly solution to the age-old problem of sore thumbs. It’s not the fastest or most durable loader on the market, but it gets the job done. At $9.49, the price is justified if you’re looking for a basic, no-frills magazine loader. I would recommend it to casual shooters who prioritize affordability over speed and durability. If you’re looking for a reliable and cost-effective way to ease your magazine loading woes, give the Butler Creek BCA2XSML ASAP a try.