Let’s Dive into Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16
The Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16 promises to alleviate the thumb-numbing pain of loading AR-15 magazines. Marketed as a universal loader with three distinct loading methods, Butler Creek aims to streamline the reloading process for both range days and tactical applications. Is this claim true?
For years, I’ve battled the tedious process of loading magazines, especially during training sessions. The goal was to find a loader that could keep up with my pace without sacrificing reliability or damaging my magazines.
Upon unboxing, the loader felt surprisingly lightweight and compact. The plastic construction appeared robust enough for range use, but I was skeptical about its long-term durability under harsh conditions.
I considered other magazine loaders like the Maglula and the ETS CAM Loader. The Butler Creek stood out with its claim of three loading methods, offering flexibility that the others didn’t.
Initially, I was optimistic but also cautious. I had hoped for a device that would dramatically reduce reloading time, but I also feared it might be too good to be true.
Real-World Testing: Putting Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16 to the Test
First Use Experience
My first test took place at an outdoor shooting range during a carbine training course. Conditions were dry and dusty, typical of a Southern California range.
The Butler Creek loader was relatively easy to use after a few practice runs, though the multi-loading feature required some finesse. However, after loading a few magazines, I noticed the rounds weren’t seating properly, leading to malfunctions during firing.
I didn’t encounter any significant issues during the initial loads, except for a bit of a learning curve on the stripper clip loading method. However, there were notable complications when using USGI Mags as the feedback indicated.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several weeks of use, the Butler Creek loader started showing signs of wear, particularly around the loading arm pivot point. The plastic began to exhibit minor stress fractures, raising concerns about its long-term reliability.
Cleaning the loader was relatively straightforward, requiring only a brush and a dry cloth to remove gunpowder residue and dirt. Despite regular maintenance, the loader’s performance with USGI magazines did not improve.
Compared to my previous experiences with simpler, single-round loaders, the Butler Creek offered faster loading with PMAGs but fell short with GI mags. I prefer the single-round loaders when using GI mags.
Breaking Down the Features of Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16
Specifications
- Manufacturer: Butler Creek
- Condition: New
- Compatibility: AR15/M16 magazines (PMAGS, but potentially not all USGI, depending on the feedback)
- Loading Methods: Single round, multi-round via loading arm (up to 10 rounds), stripper clip.
- Material: Polymer
- Weight: Very lightweight, exact weight not specified
- Universality: Claims to work with most AR15/M16 magazines
These specifications are crucial as they dictate the loader’s versatility, speed, and durability. The claim of universality is particularly important for users with a mix of magazine types.
Performance & Functionality
The Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16 performs admirably when loading PMAGs, significantly reducing loading time. Its performance falters, however, when used with standard USGI magazines, often causing rounds to bind.
Its key strengths lie in its PMAG compatibility and multiple loading methods. The primary weakness is its inconsistency with USGI mags and some feeding issues from time to time.
The product’s claim to load quickly and efficiently holds true for PMAGs, but it falls short of expectations with USGI magazines, resulting in a mixed experience. It does not perform better when using USGI mags.
Design & Ergonomics
The polymer construction makes the loader lightweight and easy to handle. The ergonomic design allows for a comfortable grip and straightforward operation, but some users might find the loading arm a bit clunky.
The Butler Creek loader is user-friendly, although mastering the multi-load technique takes practice.
Durability & Maintenance
The plastic construction raises concerns about long-term durability, especially with frequent use. Regular cleaning is essential to prevent malfunctions, but the loader’s design makes it relatively easy to maintain.
With proper care, the Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16 should last a reasonable amount of time. Replacement parts are not readily available.
Accessories and Customization Options
The Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16 does not come with additional accessories. No customization options are available.
It is compatible with standard AR15/M16 stripper clips.
Pros and Cons of Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16
Pros
- Fast loading with PMAGs. Speed is significantly increased compared to manual loading.
- Multiple loading methods. Flexibility to load single rounds, multi-rounds, or stripper clips.
- Lightweight and compact design. Easy to carry and store.
- Ergonomic grip. Comfortable to use for extended periods.
- Affordable price. A more cost-effective option compared to higher-end loaders.
Cons
- Inconsistent performance with USGI magazines. Rounds often bind and fail to seat properly.
- Plastic construction raises durability concerns. Prone to wear and potential breakage with heavy use.
- Multi-loading requires practice. The loading arm can be finicky and requires a learning curve.
Who Should Buy Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16?
The Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16 is perfect for range shooters and AR-15 enthusiasts who primarily use PMAGs and want a quick, versatile loading solution. If you are using PMAGS, this is very beneficial!
Those who primarily use USGI magazines or require a loader that can withstand extreme conditions should skip this product. You will encounter problems.
A must-have modification would be reinforcing the loading arm pivot point if possible.
Conclusion on Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16
The Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16 offers a mixed bag of performance. While it excels at loading PMAGs quickly and efficiently, its inconsistency with USGI magazines and questionable durability are significant drawbacks.
At $45.99, the price is reasonable for the convenience it offers to PMAG users. I would recommend this to anyone who needs to fill PMAGS!
Despite its flaws, the Butler Creek Asap Magazine Loader Universal AR15 / M16 is a worthwhile investment for PMAG users seeking to reduce reloading time. Consider your magazine type and usage conditions before purchasing to make the most informed decision.