Boston Leather S&W Models Holster Review

Let’s Dive into Boston Leather S&W Models Holster

The Boston Leather S&W Models Holster offers a classic, no-frills approach to carrying some of Smith & Wesson’s most iconic handguns. Specifically designed for models like the 39, 59, 469, and 659, this plain black leather holster promises reliable retention and comfortable carry. I was on the hunt for a simple, durable holster for my vintage S&W 5906, something that wouldn’t break the bank but could stand up to regular use.

After years of using Kydex and hybrid holsters, I wanted to return to the feel and aesthetic of traditional leather. The initial appeal was the promise of a comfortable, close-to-the-body carry. Upon unboxing, the Boston Leather Holster immediately struck me with its simple, functional design.

The leather felt sturdy, though a bit stiff at first, a characteristic common in new leather products. I briefly considered a DeSantis Speed Scabbard and a Galco Concealable Belt Holster, both reputable brands, but the Boston Leather offering won me over with its lower price point and straightforward design. My initial impression was cautiously optimistic; the true test would be how it performed in the field.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting Boston Leather S&W Models Holster to the Test

First Use Experience

My first outing with the Boston Leather S&W Models Holster was at an outdoor shooting range on a moderately humid day. I wanted to assess both comfort and accessibility while drawing and re-holstering. The holster felt snug against my body, minimizing printing under a light jacket.

Drawing the weapon required a deliberate tug, which I actually appreciated for added security, but could be problematic for someone needing lightning-fast access. After several draws and re-holsters, the leather started to soften, molding slightly to the shape of the pistol. One initial concern was how the holster would hold up after exposure to sweat, but the leather seemed to repel moisture surprisingly well.

Extended Use & Reliability

After a few months of regular use, including range trips and some open-carry scenarios during backcountry hikes, the Boston Leather S&W Models Holster has proven to be a reliable companion. The leather has become noticeably more supple, resulting in a smoother draw. There are some minor scratches on the surface, character marks from rubbing against branches and equipment.

Regular cleaning with leather conditioner has kept it in good shape. Compared to a more modern Kydex holster I used previously, the leather requires more care, but offers a more comfortable and traditional feel. It definitely outperforms my expectations for a holster in this price range.

Breaking Down the Features of Boston Leather S&W Models Holster

Specifications

The Boston Leather S&W Models Holster is specifically designed for the S&W Models 39, 59, 469, and 659. It is a belt holster made entirely of leather. The holster’s plain black finish gives it a classic, unassuming look.

This holster is designed to sit high and tight on the belt, providing excellent concealment and stability. The leather construction ensures durability and a comfortable fit over time. Understanding that the holster is designed for specific models ensures a secure and proper fit, reducing the risk of accidental dislodgement.

Performance & Functionality

The holster performs its primary job of securely holding the pistol exceptionally well. The retention is snug, providing a solid grip on the firearm without being overly difficult to draw. The draw stroke is consistent and reliable after a brief break-in period. One potential improvement could be the addition of a thumb break for enhanced retention, although this would increase the overall price.

The design is simple and effective, meeting the basic needs of a belt holster admirably. It may not have all the bells and whistles of more modern designs, but it’s dependable. It meets my expectations for a reliable, no-frills leather holster.

Design & Ergonomics

The Boston Leather S&W Models Holster is constructed from high-quality leather that feels substantial and well-made. Its relatively light weight ensures comfortable carry. The holster’s high-ride design keeps the firearm close to the body, aiding concealment.

The holster design is straightforward, with no complex features or adjustments. There is a slight learning curve associated with breaking in the leather, but the overall design is intuitive. The smooth leather lining protects the firearm’s finish.

Durability & Maintenance

Given its all-leather construction, the Boston Leather S&W Models Holster should provide years of reliable service with proper care. The thick leather is resistant to tearing and abrasion. Regular cleaning and conditioning are essential to prevent the leather from drying out and cracking.

Maintenance involves wiping down the holster with a damp cloth and applying a leather conditioner every few weeks. Compared to Kydex, leather requires more maintenance, but the effort is worth it for the longevity and feel. The holster is not easily repairable if damaged beyond surface scratches.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Boston Leather S&W Models Holster does not come with any included accessories, reflecting its simple design. There are no specific customization options available directly from Boston Leather. However, some users may choose to add aftermarket modifications, such as a thumb break or adjustable retention screws, although this would likely require professional leatherworking skills.

The minimalist design also means it’s broadly compatible with most standard belts. Due to its traditional design, there are limited direct customization possibilities compared to modular systems. No need for extensive modification is required, as the holster is designed to be functional right out of the box.

Pros and Cons of Boston Leather S&W Models Holster

Check Best Price HERE

Who Should Buy Boston Leather S&W Models Holster?

The Boston Leather S&W Models Holster is perfect for owners of S&W Models 39, 59, 469, and 659 who prefer a classic, traditional leather holster. It’s also ideal for those seeking a durable and affordable option for open carry or concealed carry with appropriate cover garments. Anyone who appreciates the feel and aesthetic of leather will find this holster appealing.

This holster might not be the best choice for individuals requiring lightning-fast draws in high-stress situations, as the retention is quite firm initially. Those who prefer modular, highly customizable holsters should also look elsewhere. A sturdy leather belt is a must-have accessory to ensure stability and comfort.

Conclusion on Boston Leather S&W Models Holster

In summary, the Boston Leather S&W Models Holster provides a reliable and classic solution for carrying specific S&W models. Its durable leather construction, comfortable carry, and affordable price make it an attractive option for those who appreciate traditional craftsmanship. The price of $47.99 is definitely justified given the quality and functionality.

I would personally recommend this holster to anyone seeking a simple, dependable, and time-tested design. For a classic leather holster that gets the job done without breaking the bank, the Boston Leather S&W Models Holster is a solid choice. If you’re looking for a holster that marries tradition with functionality, give this one a try!