RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins Review

Let’s Dive into RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins

The RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins are a necessary evil for reloaders who venture beyond the common Boxer-primed brass. RCBS offers these replacement pins to enable the decapping of Berdan-primed cases, which are often encountered in military surplus ammunition and certain European cartridges. These pins are designed for use with the RCBS Berdan Decapping Tool, and promise to make a tedious task somewhat more manageable.

My journey to the RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins began with a large stash of 8mm Mauser ammunition I acquired years ago. While most of it was reloadable Boxer-primed brass, a significant portion turned out to be Berdan-primed. Knowing I couldn’t simply punch out the primers with a standard decapping die, I needed a dedicated solution.

Upon unboxing, the first thing I noticed was the simplicity. The RCBS Berdan Decapping Pin is a small, steel pin, and there is no elaborate packaging. It’s a functional tool, and initial inspection revealed a seemingly well-machined piece, though its slender profile raised concerns about potential fragility.

Compared to other decapping methods (like hydraulic decapping), the RCBS system promised a more controlled and less messy approach, so I went with these pins to make my decapping process easier. The universal decapping dies won’t work with berdan primed cases, and hydraulic is messy, so there are not a lot of great options. I picked this particular product because of the RCBS brand name and the hope of quality construction.

My initial impression was a mix of hope and apprehension. I was excited at the prospect of finally reloading my Berdan-primed brass. However, I was equally worried about the fragility of the pins, a common complaint I’d encountered in online forums.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins to the Test

First Use Experience

I tested the RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins in my reloading workshop, primarily working with 8mm Mauser brass. I used the RCBS Berdan Decapping Tool with the pin installed and followed the instructions carefully, ensuring proper case alignment to avoid bending or breaking the pin.

The pin performed adequately in dry conditions, but some cases required considerable force to remove the primers. When encountering harder-to-remove primers, the pin seemed to flex noticeably, causing increased worry about breakage.

The learning curve was minimal. The tool is relatively straightforward, but the feel of the pin engaging the Berdan primers required some getting used to. Proper setup and alignment are critical to avoid damaging the pin or the case.

The most significant issue I encountered during the first use was the pin bending on a few particularly stubborn primers. This reinforced my initial concerns about the pin’s fragility.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks and hundreds of cases, the RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins showed moderate wear. The pin itself remains functional, though the tip is showing signs of slight deformation from repeated use.

Despite careful use, I have broken two pins. This has highlighted the importance of having spares on hand.

Maintaining the tool is simple: a quick wipe-down with a clean cloth after each use. I also apply a light coat of oil to prevent rust, which is something the other user noted in the reviews.

Compared to my previous attempts at decapping Berdan-primed brass using makeshift methods, the RCBS system is far more controlled and efficient. However, the pin’s fragility is a significant drawback compared to the robust nature of standard decapping pins used for Boxer-primed brass.

Breaking Down the Features of RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins

Specifications

• The RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins are made of steel. This provides the necessary hardness to pierce the primer compound and force the primer out of the case.
• They are silver in color, a standard finish for steel tools. The color has no bearing on the function of the pins.
• Each package contains one pin. This is a significant downside.
• The Country of Origin is the USA, a fact that should indicate quality.
• These pins are designed to decap 8mm Rimless, 6.5 mm Mannlicher-Schoenauer, and 11.7mm Rimmed, and other cartridges with Berdan primers. The tip design and pin diameter are optimized for the smaller Berdan primer pockets, which feature two off-center flash holes.

These specifications are crucial because the hardness of the steel determines the pin’s ability to penetrate the primer. The precise dimensions of the pin are critical for proper fitment within the Berdan primer pocket and ensuring effective primer removal without damaging the case. The fact that only one pin is included per package highlights the high probability of breakage.

Performance & Functionality

The RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins perform their intended job, but with caveats. They successfully decap Berdan-primed cases, albeit with a higher risk of breakage compared to standard decapping pins.

The primary weakness is the pin’s fragility. It bends and breaks relatively easily if excessive force is applied or if the case is not perfectly aligned.

While the RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins do perform their intended task, their tendency to break makes the process frustrating and expensive. They meet expectations in that they do decap, but they fall short in terms of reliability and longevity.

Design & Ergonomics

The build quality is decent for a small steel pin. The steel seems well-machined and hardened appropriately.

The design is straightforward and functional. There is virtually no learning curve beyond understanding how to align and operate the decapping tool itself.

Durability & Maintenance

The RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins are not particularly durable. Expect to break pins, especially when working with older or corroded brass.

Maintenance is minimal. Keeping the pin clean and lightly oiled will help prevent rust, but it won’t extend its lifespan significantly.

Accessories and Customization Options

There are no accessories or customization options for the RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins themselves. The pins are designed to work exclusively with the RCBS Berdan Decapping Tool.

The RCBS Berdan Decapping Tool accepts only these pins. There are no known compatible accessories from other brands.

Pros and Cons of RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins

Check Best Price HERE

Who Should Buy RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins?

The RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins are perfect for reloaders who:

• Have a significant quantity of Berdan-primed brass that they want to reload.
• Are willing to take extra care and use a gentle touch during the decapping process.
• Don’t mind purchasing multiple replacement pins.

Those who should skip this product:

• Reloaders who primarily work with Boxer-primed brass.
• Those who are impatient or tend to apply excessive force when reloading.
• Those who find the cost of replacement pins prohibitive.

Must-have accessories or modifications:

• Several spare RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins.
• A high-quality case lubricant to help ease primer removal.
• A magnifying glass to carefully inspect cases and ensure proper alignment.

Conclusion on RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins

The RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins serve a niche purpose, enabling the decapping of Berdan-primed cases. However, their fragility is a significant drawback that cannot be ignored. The high cost of replacement pins, coupled with their short lifespan, makes this a frustrating product to use.

The price is difficult to justify given the pin’s propensity to break. A more robust design or a lower price point would significantly improve the value proposition.

I would only recommend the RCBS Berdan Decapping Pins to reloaders who absolutely need to decap Berdan-primed brass and are willing to accept the high cost and frustration associated with frequent pin breakage. Proceed with caution and purchase plenty of spares.