Hornady Shell Holders Review

Let’s Dive into Hornady Shell Holders

The Hornady Shell Holders are a seemingly simple, yet absolutely critical component for anyone involved in reloading ammunition. Manufactured by Hornady, these small, unassuming pieces of steel ensure that the cartridge case is held securely and precisely aligned within the reloading press during various stages of the reloading process. They are the unsung heroes that guarantee consistent and safe ammunition production.

My reloading journey began with a frustrating inability to consistently produce accurate rounds. The problem, I soon discovered, wasn’t my technique, but rather inconsistencies in case alignment during the seating process. This led me down the rabbit hole of finding the perfect shell holder, ultimately landing on Hornady.

My initial experience with the Hornady Shell Holders was, well, uneventful – exactly as it should be. They felt solid and well-made straight out of the packaging. The design is straightforward; a hardened steel ring with precisely machined internal dimensions to fit specific cartridge case heads.

I had previously used a universal shell holder, and some generic shell holders from an unnamed manufacturer that came bundled with a used press I purchased. The universal holder was finicky and imprecise. The generics were poorly made and prone to slipping. The Hornady Shell Holders provided a secure fit with none of the slop of the universal or generic options. The secure fit allowed for consistent and accurate reloading.

I was initially relieved. After all, how excited can one get about a shell holder? But, the precision and reliability quickly won me over. The consistent results they facilitated made the entire reloading process smoother and more enjoyable.


Real-World Testing: Putting Hornady Shell Holders to the Test

First Use Experience

My primary testing ground for the Hornady Shell Holders is my reloading bench in my garage. Typically, I’m reloading for various calibers, from .223 Remington for my AR-15 to .45 ACP for my 1911. I primarily reload in a controlled indoor environment, but the unheated garage can get quite cold in the winter, and dusty during the dry summer months.

The Hornady Shell Holders performed consistently well, regardless of the temperature or dust levels. They securely held the cartridge cases throughout the resizing, priming, powder charging, and bullet seating stages. There were no noticeable issues with slippage or misalignment, even with slightly tarnished or older brass.

The Hornady Shell Holders are incredibly easy to use. Simply select the correct shell holder for your cartridge and insert it into the press ram. From there, it’s just a matter of feeding the cases in and out. No special tools or techniques are required.

Extended Use & Reliability

After a year of consistent use, the Hornady Shell Holders have proven to be incredibly durable. There is no visible wear and tear on the shell holders themselves. They continue to provide a secure and reliable grip on the cartridge cases.

Maintenance is minimal. A quick wipe down with a clean cloth after each reloading session is usually sufficient. I occasionally apply a very light coat of gun oil to prevent rust, especially during humid months, though that is likely unnecessary.

These shell holders significantly outperformed my previous experiences with the universal and generic shell holders. The Hornady‘s precision and reliability have resulted in more consistent ammunition and less wasted components. The investment in quality shell holders has paid off handsomely in terms of improved accuracy and reduced frustration.

Breaking Down the Features of Hornady Shell Holders

Specifications

  • The Hornady Shell Holders are constructed from hardened steel. This provides excellent durability and resistance to wear.
  • Each shell holder is specifically machined to fit the base of a particular cartridge case. This ensures a precise and secure fit, minimizing the risk of misalignment during reloading.
  • The Hornady Shell Holders are designed to work seamlessly with Hornady reloading presses and many other brands. This offers broad compatibility for reloaders.
  • They are priced at $2.49. This makes them an accessible and affordable investment for reloaders.

These specifications matter because they directly impact the quality and consistency of reloaded ammunition. The hardened steel construction ensures longevity, while the precise machining guarantees proper case alignment. The alignment promotes consistent bullet seating and reduces the risk of case damage. The price is competitive and appropriate for the quality of the item.

Performance & Functionality

The Hornady Shell Holders perform their job exceptionally well. They hold cartridge cases securely, allowing for precise and consistent reloading. The secure fit is critical for achieving consistent neck tension and proper bullet seating depth.

The strength lies in their simplicity and precision. There are no moving parts to fail. The exactness of the fit guarantees that the case is held firmly in the correct position. A minor improvement could be the inclusion of a small detent to positively lock the shell holder into the press ram, although this is a minor quibble.

The Hornady Shell Holders far exceed expectations. They perform a simple task flawlessly and consistently, contributing significantly to the overall quality of reloaded ammunition. They inspire confidence in my reloading process.

Design & Ergonomics

The design of the Hornady Shell Holders is simple and functional. The hardened steel construction feels robust and durable in hand. The shell holders are sized to fit specific cartridges.

The shell holders are extremely user-friendly. There’s essentially no learning curve. Even a novice reloader can easily insert and remove cartridge cases from the shell holder with minimal effort.

Durability & Maintenance

These shell holders are built to last a lifetime with proper care. The hardened steel construction is incredibly resistant to wear and tear. The resistance to wear ensures years of reliable service.

Maintenance is straightforward. A quick wipe down with a clean cloth after each use is usually sufficient. A light coat of gun oil can be applied periodically to prevent rust, but this is not essential.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Hornady Shell Holders do not come with any specific accessories, as they are a standalone component. However, they are compatible with a wide range of reloading presses and dies from various manufacturers.

The are no customization options beyond selecting the correct shell holder for the specific cartridge you are reloading. Their compatibility with standard reloading equipment makes them a versatile and valuable addition to any reloader’s arsenal.

Pros and Cons of Hornady Shell Holders

Pros

  • Extremely durable hardened steel construction guarantees a long service life.
  • Precisely machined to ensure a secure and accurate fit for specific cartridge cases.
  • Compatible with a wide range of reloading presses and dies.
  • Simple and easy to use, even for novice reloaders.
  • Affordable at only $2.49.

Cons

  • Requires purchasing a separate shell holder for each cartridge case head size, which adds to the overall cost of reloading.
  • The shell holder is easy to misplace due to its small size, so storage organization is important.


Who Should Buy Hornady Shell Holders?

The Hornady Shell Holders are perfect for any reloader who wants to produce consistent and accurate ammunition. From casual hobbyists to competitive shooters, these shell holders provide a reliable foundation for the reloading process. Hunters will appreciate the ability to create custom loads tailored to their specific rifles and hunting conditions.

Anyone who is looking for a “one-size-fits-all” solution should skip this product. A universal shell holder may be more appealing initially, but it will not provide the same level of precision and reliability. Similarly, reloaders who are only working with a single cartridge may find the need to purchase multiple shell holders unnecessary.

A good reloading manual and a set of quality dies are must-have accessories to get the most out of the Hornady Shell Holders. Organization is also important. A dedicated storage container or rack will help keep the shell holders organized and prevent them from getting lost.

Conclusion on Hornady Shell Holders

The Hornady Shell Holders are a seemingly simple product, but they are essential for producing high-quality reloaded ammunition. Their durable construction, precise machining, and ease of use make them a valuable addition to any reloader’s bench. For a mere $2.49, these are a no-brainer for any serious reloader.

The price is absolutely justified. The Hornady Shell Holders offer exceptional value for the money. Their performance and longevity far outweigh the minimal cost.

I would wholeheartedly recommend the Hornady Shell Holders to any reloader. They are a small investment that yields significant returns in terms of accuracy, consistency, and overall reloading satisfaction. Invest in the proper tools and components. Start creating some awesome ammunition today!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top