Let’s Dive into El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather
The El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather holster is a classic piece, designed for the discerning 1911 carrier. It’s a high-ride, thumb-break holster promising both comfort and secure retention, crafted by the renowned El Paso Saddlery. Its flat-back construction and full pistol coverage hint at a practical design aimed at duty and concealed carry.
I needed a reliable and comfortable holster for my Commander-sized 1911 for both range days and potential concealed carry. I was looking for a holster that prioritized retention and comfort without sacrificing accessibility.
Upon unboxing, the aroma of genuine leather immediately filled the air, a testament to the El Paso Saddlery’s commitment to quality. The holster felt solid, with a noticeable weight that spoke to its sturdy construction.
I considered a Kydex holster known for its rigidity and a hybrid holster with a leather backing and Kydex shell. However, I chose the El Paso Saddlery holster for its classic aesthetic, proven leather durability, and the added security of a thumb-break. The promise of all-day comfort was a significant factor in my decision.
My first impression was a pleasant surprise: a blend of old-world craftsmanship and practical design. I was eager to see how it performed in real-world scenarios, hoping it would live up to the reputation of El Paso Saddlery.
Real-World Testing: Putting El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather to the Test
First Use Experience
I initially tested the El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather at an outdoor shooting range. I focused on drawing and re-holstering drills, assessing the holster’s speed and ease of use under pressure.
During a light rain shower, the leather maintained its grip and shape, proving its resistance to minor environmental factors. The thumb-break released smoothly even with slightly damp hands, ensuring consistent access to the firearm.
While the high-ride design initially felt different from my usual mid-ride holsters, I quickly adapted to the positioning. The secure fit and easy draw became intuitive after only a few repetitions.
The initial draw was slightly stiff, requiring a firm tug to clear the holster. However, after a few practice draws, the leather began to mold to my firearm, and the draw became smoother and more natural.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several weeks of consistent use, the El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather has proven to be a reliable companion. The leather has softened and molded to my body, enhancing comfort during extended wear.
Despite daily use and exposure to varying temperatures, the holster shows minimal wear and tear. The stitching remains tight, and the leather retains its shape, indicating a robust construction.
Cleaning is straightforward, requiring only occasional wiping with a damp cloth and periodic leather conditioning. This simple maintenance ensures the holster maintains its appearance and functionality.
Compared to previous Kydex holsters, the El Paso Saddlery holster offers superior comfort and a more secure hold. The thumb-break provides an added layer of security, while the leather molds to the body for a custom fit.
Breaking Down the Features of El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather
Specifications
The El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather holster is specifically designed for a 1911 Commander with a 4.5″ barrel. It’s constructed of high-quality leather and is designed for right-handed users.
- Manufacturer: El Paso Saddlery.
- Gun Model: 1911.
- Holster Material: Leather.
- Hand: Right.
- Accessory Attachment System: Belt Loop.
- Finish: Leather.
- Gun Type: Pistol.
- # of Mag Pouch Compartments: 1.
These specifications are crucial because they guarantee a secure and tailored fit for the intended firearm. The leather construction ensures durability and comfort, while the belt loop attachment provides a stable and reliable carry.
Performance & Functionality
The El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather performs its job exceptionally well. It provides a secure, comfortable, and accessible carry option for a 1911 Commander.
Its strength lies in its balance of retention, comfort, and ease of draw, however the initial stiffness requires a break-in period. It far exceeded my expectations regarding comfort.
Design & Ergonomics
The build quality is top-notch, with high-quality leather and precise stitching. The holster’s weight is substantial, lending a sense of security and durability, and it is surprisingly comfortable against the body.
The holster is designed for ease of use, with an intuitive thumb-break release and a natural draw angle. There is minimal learning curve, and the holster quickly becomes an extension of the user.
Durability & Maintenance
The El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather is built to last, crafted from durable leather that can withstand daily wear and tear. With proper care, this holster should provide years of reliable service.
Maintenance is simple, requiring only periodic cleaning and conditioning to maintain the leather’s integrity. The robust construction and quality materials minimize the need for repairs.
Accessories and Customization Options
The holster features a single magazine pouch compartment, providing convenient storage for an extra magazine. While customization options are limited due to the holster’s traditional design, the leather can be treated and conditioned to suit individual preferences.
The holster is compatible with standard-sized belts, allowing for seamless integration with existing carry systems. It is designed to work well with a variety of 1911 magazines and accessories.
Pros and Cons of El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather
Pros
- Classic design and aesthetic: The holster offers a timeless, professional look.
- Superior comfort: The leather molds to the body for a custom fit and all-day comfort.
- Secure retention: The thumb-break provides an added layer of security.
- Durable construction: High-quality leather and precise stitching ensure longevity.
- Easy to maintain: Simple cleaning and conditioning keep the holster in top condition.
Cons
- The initial draw may be stiff, requiring a break-in period.
- Limited customization options compared to modular holster systems.
Who Should Buy El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather?
This holster is perfect for 1911 enthusiasts, law enforcement officers, and concealed carry permit holders who appreciate classic craftsmanship and reliable performance. It is ideal for those who prioritize comfort, security, and a professional appearance.
This product may not be the best choice for those who prefer highly customizable or modular holster systems. Those seeking a quick-draw, competition-style holster might also find this model too restrictive.
A high-quality leather belt is a must-have accessory to ensure proper holster support and stability. Regular leather conditioning products will also help maintain the holster’s appearance and longevity.
Conclusion on El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather
The El Paso Saddlery ST1911RB Strong Side Select 1911 Commander 4.5″ Barrel Leather is a superb holster that blends classic design with practical functionality. Its comfortable carry, secure retention, and durable construction make it a worthwhile investment for any 1911 owner.
At $95.99, the price is justified by the quality of materials and craftsmanship. It’s a holster built to last, offering a significant upgrade over cheaper alternatives.
I would wholeheartedly recommend the El Paso Saddlery holster to anyone seeking a reliable and comfortable carry option for their 1911 Commander. Invest in quality, embrace the classic design, and experience the El Paso Saddlery difference.