What Makes USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models Stand Out?
The USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models is a holster designed for Glock 34/35 pistols, offering a blend of speed and security in a concealment-friendly package. Made by Safariland, a brand synonymous with law enforcement and tactical gear, this particular model promises a reliable draw with its open-top design and the added retention of a detent in the trigger guard. The fact that it’s used, and specifically described as “Condition Fair, Scratches”, presents both a cost-saving opportunity and a potential gamble on its remaining lifespan. This review will dive deep into whether this particular Safariland holster, despite its used condition, is still a worthwhile investment.
I was in the market for a holster that could accommodate my Glock 34 for range use and potential concealed carry in less restrictive environments. I needed something with good retention, but also a fast draw, and the open-top design seemed ideal. The lower price point of a used holster was certainly appealing, especially since Safariland gear is generally built to last.
My first impression upon receiving the holster was mixed, as expected given its “fair” condition. The STX Tactical Black finish showed noticeable scratches, indicative of prior use and wear. However, the overall construction felt solid, and the paddle/belt loop attachment seemed secure.
I was considering a brand-new Safariland 7378RDS 7TS ALS holster or a Blackhawk Serpa holster, but ultimately chose this used option for the lower price and the proven reputation of Safariland’s ALS system, even in this simpler configuration. The potential savings outweighed the cosmetic imperfections. I felt a cautious optimism – hoping the holster’s core functionality remained intact despite its visible wear.
Real-World Testing: Putting USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models to the Test
First Use Experience
My initial testing took place at an outdoor shooting range. The weather was dry and sunny, providing ideal conditions to assess the holster’s draw speed and retention. I practiced drawing and re-holstering drills repeatedly, focusing on consistency and secure weapon handling.
The draw stroke felt surprisingly smooth and fast, despite the detent in the trigger guard. There was a definite “click” as the pistol seated, providing audible and tactile confirmation of secure retention. However, the scratches on the exterior did create some minor friction during the draw, something I’ll address later.
One immediate concern was the paddle attachment’s stability during rapid movements. While adequate for casual range use, it exhibited some wobble during simulated tactical scenarios, suggesting the need for a more secure belt attachment for serious concealed carry.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several weeks of regular use, the holster’s retention mechanism remains reliable. The detent still provides a positive “click,” and the pistol feels secure even during moderate physical activity. The STX Tactical finish, however, continues to show signs of wear, with the scratches becoming more pronounced.
Durability-wise, the holster has held up reasonably well, considering its pre-existing condition. There are no signs of structural damage, and the paddle attachment remains functional, though I did replace it with a Safariland belt loop attachment for greater stability. Cleaning is straightforward; a quick wipe down with a damp cloth removes any dirt or debris.
Compared to previous experiences with cheaper holsters, the Safariland offers a significant improvement in both retention and draw speed. While the used condition is a factor, the core design and construction demonstrate the quality that Safariland is known for. However, the cosmetic wear and less-than-ideal paddle attachment are drawbacks that impact the overall experience.
Breaking Down the Features of USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models
Specifications
This Safariland 5198-683-131 holster is specifically designed for Glock 34/35 pistols. It is a right-hand configuration.
The holster features an open-top design with a detent in the trigger guard for weapon retention. It is constructed from Safariland’s proprietary STX Tactical material, finished in black.
It comes with a paddle attachment for quick on/off and can be converted to a belt loop configuration. The condition is listed as “Fair” with visible scratches.
These specifications are crucial because they dictate the holster’s compatibility, retention level, and concealment potential. The Glock 34/35 fit ensures a snug and secure hold, while the open-top design allows for a rapid draw. The STX Tactical material provides a durable, weather-resistant exterior.
Performance & Functionality
The USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models performs its primary function—holstering and retaining a Glock 34/35—reliably. The open-top design facilitates a fast draw, while the detent provides adequate security for everyday carry. However, the used condition and the limitations of the paddle attachment detract from its overall performance.
The holster’s strength lies in its secure retention and relatively fast draw. A notable weakness is the “fair” cosmetic condition which affects the smoothness of the draw. It meets the basic expectations for a Safariland holster, but falls short of a new model’s pristine performance.
Design & Ergonomics
The Safariland 5198 boasts a compact and lightweight design. The low-cut sides enhance comfort and facilitate a cleaner draw stroke.
The build quality is typically excellent for Safariland products, although the used condition affects the overall impression. The paddle attachment, while convenient, introduces some wobble and instability. There’s a slight learning curve associated with mastering the draw, particularly disengaging the detent smoothly and efficiently.
Durability & Maintenance
The Safariland 5198 is inherently durable, constructed from robust STX Tactical material. However, the used condition suggests a reduced lifespan compared to a new holster.
Maintenance is simple, requiring only occasional cleaning with a damp cloth. Replacing worn-out components, such as the paddle attachment, can extend the holster’s service life.
Accessories and Customization Options
The Safariland 5198 comes standard with a paddle attachment and hardware for converting to a belt loop. Aftermarket accessories include various belt loop adaptors and leg shrouds.
The holster is compatible with a range of Safariland accessories, allowing users to customize its carry style and security level. This includes the popular QLS (Quick Locking System) which allows for rapid holster swaps.
Pros and Cons of USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models
Pros
- Fast and smooth draw due to the open-top design.
- Secure weapon retention thanks to the detent in the trigger guard.
- Durable STX Tactical material construction.
- Affordable price point, making it a budget-friendly option for a trusted brand.
- Lightweight and compact design for comfortable concealed carry.
Cons
- Visible scratches and wear, affecting aesthetics and draw smoothness.
- Paddle attachment offers less stability than belt loop options.
- The “Fair” condition raises concerns about the holster’s long-term durability.
Who Should Buy USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models?
The USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models is perfect for budget-conscious shooters looking for a reliable Safariland holster for range use or occasional concealed carry. It’s also a good option for those who want to experiment with different carry styles without investing heavily in new gear.
Those seeking a pristine, like-new holster or requiring maximum stability for duty use should skip this product. They should opt for a new Safariland model or explore alternative brands with more robust attachment systems. A must-have accessory is a Safariland belt loop attachment for increased stability and security, especially for concealed carry purposes.
Conclusion on USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models
The USED Safariland 5198 Open Top Concealment – 1 out of 69 models offers a compelling value proposition for budget-minded individuals willing to overlook cosmetic imperfections. While the scratches and used condition are undeniable, the holster retains the core functionality and durability that Safariland is known for. At $40.50, the price is certainly justified, providing access to a proven design at a fraction of the cost of a new holster.
I would personally recommend this holster with reservations. If you prioritize functionality over aesthetics and are comfortable with its used condition, it’s a solid choice.
If you’re looking for a reliable and affordable holster that balances speed and security, consider giving this USED Safariland a chance. Just be prepared for some cosmetic blemishes and consider upgrading the attachment system for optimal performance!