CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR Review

First Thoughts on the CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR

The CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR promises tighter, denser patterns for waterfowl hunting, a claim that immediately piqued my interest. As someone who’s spent years trying to improve my shot consistency in the marsh, a better choke tube is always on my radar. This choke, manufactured by CARL, boasts a longer parallel section for improved patterns and construction from 1704 stainless steel.

My waterfowl shooting had become frustrating. I’d patterned my shotgun with various loads, but I struggled to get consistent results at longer ranges. I had been using factory choke tubes, which are generally adequate, but I wanted something that would deliver more consistent, denser patterns for those challenging crossing shots on wary ducks and geese. I wanted an edge, and the CARL CREMATOR seemed to offer just that.

Upon receiving the CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR, I was immediately impressed with the machining quality. The stainless steel felt robust and the knurled end provided a solid grip. Compared to my factory choke tubes, it was noticeably heavier and seemed much more durable. I also considered the Patternmaster Code Black Duck and the Briley Spectrum chokes, but the CARL CREMATOR won out due to its promise of a longer parallel section and aggressive knurling at a significantly lower price point.

My first impression was excitement tempered with cautious optimism. A lot of choke tubes make big promises, but rarely fully deliver. I was eager to get it out into the field and see if the CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR could truly live up to the hype.

Real-World Testing: Putting CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR to the Test

First Use Experience

I tested the CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR during the early teal season in a flooded rice field in Arkansas. The conditions were typical: humid, with temperatures hovering around 80 degrees. I used 3-inch, #2 steel shot, a common load for teal. The choke installed easily into my Winchester Super X3, no tools required.

The difference in pattern density was immediately noticeable. I folded teal at distances that previously would have required a follow-up shot. The choke seemed to perform equally well with close-range shots, providing a reasonably open pattern. I had no issues with cycling or any malfunctions directly attributable to the choke tube itself.

There were no immediate issues, but I did notice that the choke tube got quite hot after several shots. It wasn’t a major problem, but it was something to keep in mind when handling it for cleaning.

Extended Use & Reliability

After three months of use throughout the waterfowl season, the CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR has held up remarkably well. There are no signs of corrosion or wear, despite regular exposure to water and mud. I routinely clean the choke tube after each hunt with a solvent and brush, and it’s an easy process. The knurled end makes it simple to remove, even with muddy hands.

Compared to my previous experiences with factory chokes, the CARL CREMATOR has provided noticeably tighter and more consistent patterns at longer ranges. This has translated to cleaner kills and fewer cripples, which is the ultimate goal for any ethical hunter. It outperforms factory chokes consistently.

Breaking Down the Features of CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR

Specifications

  • The CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR is manufactured from 1704 stainless steel. This material is known for its durability and resistance to corrosion, making it ideal for use in harsh hunting environments.
  • It is designed for waterfowl and features extended length. This extended length is intended to create tighter, denser patterns compared to standard choke tubes.
  • The choke has a 25% longer parallel section. This longer parallel section helps to maintain consistent constriction, resulting in improved pattern consistency.
  • It includes a knurled end for easy removal. The knurled end allows for quick and easy removal and installation, even with gloved or wet hands.
  • The constriction and size are laser marked on the end and body. These laser markings provide clear and easy identification of the choke’s specifications.

Performance & Functionality

The CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR excels at delivering tighter, denser patterns at longer ranges. This translates to increased confidence in making those challenging shots on waterfowl. It performed as advertised, significantly improving pattern density.

The choke’s strengths lie in its consistent performance and easy handling. However, it can become quite hot after extended use and may require a heat-resistant glove for removal. It meets expectations and provides added confidence.

Design & Ergonomics

The CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR features a robust design using high-quality materials. The stainless steel construction provides excellent durability and corrosion resistance. Its weight is noticeable but does not negatively impact the shotgun’s balance.

The knurled end makes it incredibly user-friendly. There is no significant learning curve. Installation and removal are effortless.

Durability & Maintenance

Given the 1704 stainless steel construction, the CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR is built to last. Regular cleaning and lubrication will ensure its longevity. It should last for many seasons with proper care.

Maintenance is straightforward. A simple cleaning with solvent and a brush is all that’s required.

Accessories and Customization Options

The CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR does not come with any additional accessories. However, it is compatible with any shotgun that accepts Winchester, Browning Invector Plus (depending on model) and Mossberg 500 series style choke tubes. There are no customization options directly related to the choke itself, but it enhances the performance of the entire shotgun system.

Pros and Cons of CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR

Pros

    • Dramatically improved pattern density at extended ranges.
    • Durable 1704 stainless steel construction.
    • Easy removal and installation thanks to the knurled end.
    • Clearly marked constriction and size for easy identification.
    • Noticeably enhances confidence in shooting performance.

Cons

    • Can become hot after extended use.
    • No included accessories.
    • May not be ideal for extremely close-range shooting scenarios.


Who Should Buy CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR?

The CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR is perfect for waterfowl hunters who are looking to improve their pattern density and effective range. It benefits hunters who frequently encounter shots at distances beyond 30 yards. This choke is beneficial to all levels of hunter.

This choke is not for hunters who primarily hunt in close-quarters environments, such as timber, where extremely open patterns are necessary. It might also be overkill for beginners still learning basic shooting techniques.

A choke tube wrench can be helpful, although not strictly necessary due to the knurled end. A good quality gun cleaning solvent and brush are essential for maintaining the choke’s performance.

Conclusion on CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR

The CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR delivers on its promise of tighter, denser patterns for waterfowl hunting. The stainless steel construction and user-friendly design make it a valuable addition to any serious waterfowler’s gear. It’s a worthwhile investment for anyone looking to improve their shooting performance.

The price of $41.99 is justified given the choke’s performance and durability. It is a solid value.

I would highly recommend the CARL CREMATOR NON PTD WIN MR to any waterfowl hunter looking to enhance their shooting performance. Upgrade your shotgun today and experience the difference for yourself!


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top