SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM Review

First Thoughts on the SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM

The SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM is a seemingly simple piece of kit, yet it represents a crucial tool for revolver enthusiasts who prioritize speed and efficiency in reloading. Manufactured by Safariland, a trusted name in law enforcement and tactical gear, this speedloader promises to streamline the process of replenishing ammunition in revolvers chambered in .357 Magnum and .38 Special.

I initially sought this product because of my increasing interest in revolver shooting competitions and practical drills. My manual reloads were simply too slow, costing me valuable time during stages. I needed a reliable and consistent method to quickly reload my Smith & Wesson K-frame revolver.

The speedloader arrives in simple packaging, but the product itself feels solid and well-made. The black polymer construction feels robust enough to withstand the rigors of regular use. The initial impression is that it is a practical, no-frills tool designed for a specific purpose.

Comparing it to other speedloaders on the market, such as the HKS speedloader, the Safariland COMP II stands out due to its push-in release mechanism, which promises a faster and more intuitive reload. I chose this model specifically over the twist-knob style loaders, hoping the push-in design would prove more efficient under pressure. I was eager to test the speed and ease of use touted by Safariland.

My initial feeling was one of cautious optimism. The design seemed promising, but I was also aware that speedloaders can be finicky if they are not properly sized or if the release mechanism isn’t reliable. Only real-world testing would determine whether the SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM would live up to its potential.

Real-World Testing: Putting SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM to the Test

First Use Experience

I tested the SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM primarily at my local shooting range during a series of timed revolver drills. I focused on drawing my Smith & Wesson Model 19, firing a cylinder of .38 Special rounds, and then reloading using the Safariland speedloader.

The initial experience was positive; the speedloader aligned easily with the cylinder of my K-frame. The push-in release was indeed faster than the twist-knob style speedloaders I had previously tried. However, I did experience a few instances where the rounds didn’t fully release into the cylinder without a slight nudge.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of regular use, the SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM has proven to be a reliable addition to my range gear. The polymer construction has held up well, showing no signs of cracking or deformation despite being dropped on concrete multiple times.

Cleaning is simple: I usually just wipe it down with a cloth after each range session to remove any powder residue or debris. The release mechanism continues to function smoothly, although I still occasionally encounter the issue of rounds not fully releasing without a slight assist. This is more prevalent with certain brands of ammunition, suggesting it might be related to slight variations in cartridge dimensions. I have found that regular cleaning prevents build-up that might exacerbate this tendency.

Compared to my previous experiences with other speedloaders, the SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM offers a noticeable improvement in speed and ease of use. The push-in release is significantly faster and more intuitive than the twist-knob designs, especially when under pressure. It has certainly improved my performance in timed drills and competitions.

Breaking Down the Features of SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM

Specifications

The SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM is specifically designed for revolvers chambered in .357 Magnum and .38 Special. It holds five rounds, making it suitable for revolvers like the Smith & Wesson K-frame (Model 10, 19, 66), Dan Wesson .38/.357, and Taurus 66/669/689.

The speedloader is constructed from a durable, black polymer. The polymer is impact-resistant and designed to withstand the rigors of regular use. It weighs approximately 1.6 ounces, making it lightweight and easy to carry in a pouch or on a belt.

The key feature is the push-in release mechanism, which allows for quick and intuitive reloading. Simply align the speedloader with the cylinder and push the rounds into the chambers; the speedloader automatically releases, leaving the rounds in place. This is a significant advantage over twist-knob designs, which require an extra step to release the ammunition.

Performance & Functionality

The SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM performs its primary function—reloading a revolver quickly and efficiently—very well. The speedloader consistently aligns with the cylinder, and the push-in release mechanism is easy to operate, even with gloved hands.

However, as noted earlier, the occasional failure of rounds to fully release without a slight nudge is a minor weakness. This issue can be minimized by using high-quality ammunition and regularly cleaning the speedloader. Overall, the SL COMP II meets expectations and offers a significant improvement in reloading speed compared to manual methods.

Design & Ergonomics

The black polymer construction feels solid and well-made. The design is simple and functional, with no unnecessary frills. The lightweight construction makes it comfortable to carry in a speedloader pouch or on a belt without adding excessive weight.

The SL COMP II is user-friendly, with a minimal learning curve. The push-in release mechanism is intuitive and easy to master with a little practice. Its smooth edges ensure it doesn’t snag on clothing during quick reloads.

Durability & Maintenance

The durable polymer construction suggests that the SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM will last for many years with proper care. The polymer is resistant to impacts, scratches, and most common solvents.

Maintenance is simple, requiring only occasional cleaning with a cloth or brush to remove powder residue and debris. Disassembly is not required for routine cleaning, which simplifies the process.

Accessories and Customization Options

The SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM is a standalone product and does not require any additional accessories for basic functionality. However, it is essential to purchase speedloader pouches for convenient and secure carry. Many manufacturers offer pouches specifically designed for the Safariland COMP II speedloaders.

There are no direct customization options available for the speedloader itself, but the user can choose from a wide variety of speedloader pouches in different materials, colors, and mounting configurations. Proper pouches are crucial for ensuring quick access to the speedloaders during competitions or tactical scenarios.

Pros and Cons of SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM

Pros

  • Significantly faster reloads compared to manual loading.
  • Intuitive push-in release mechanism is easy to use under pressure.
  • Durable polymer construction withstands regular use and abuse.
  • Lightweight and comfortable to carry in a pouch.
  • Compatible with a wide range of K-frame revolvers.

Cons

  • Rounds may occasionally require a slight nudge to fully release.
  • Requires compatible speedloader pouches for convenient carry (additional expense).


Who Should Buy SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM?

The SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM is perfect for: competitive shooters, revolver enthusiasts who prioritize speed and efficiency, law enforcement officers who carry K-frame revolvers as backup weapons, and anyone looking to improve their reloading skills with a revolver.

Who should skip this product? Individuals who rarely shoot revolvers or do not prioritize fast reloads. Those who prefer other reloading methods, such as moon clips, may also find the SL COMP II unnecessary.

Must-have accessories or modifications? High-quality speedloader pouches are essential for convenient and secure carry. Experimenting with different brands of ammunition can help identify cartridges that work most reliably with the speedloader.

Conclusion on SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM

The SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM is a well-designed and effective speedloader that offers a significant improvement in reloading speed for K-frame revolvers. Its intuitive push-in release mechanism and durable polymer construction make it a reliable tool for competitive shooters and revolver enthusiasts alike.

At a price of $16.00, the SL COMP II offers excellent value for its performance and durability. The slight issue of rounds occasionally requiring a nudge is a minor inconvenience that can be minimized with proper ammunition selection and maintenance.

I would personally recommend the SL COMP II SPD LDR S&W K-FRM to anyone looking to improve their reloading speed with a K-frame revolver. It is a worthwhile investment that will enhance your shooting experience and potentially improve your performance in competitions or tactical scenarios. Upgrade your reloading game today with the Safariland COMP II!


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top