First Impressions of Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog
The Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog promises a simple, functional, and affordable way to carry a broadsword. As someone who appreciates historical weaponry and often participates in reenactments, I was eager to see if this frog could provide a practical solution without breaking the bank. I’ve struggled in the past with poorly made frogs that either fall apart or don’t securely hold the sword, so I was looking for something that offered decent quality at a reasonable price point.
What led me to this product was the need for a functional sword-carrying solution for a stage production. The budget was tight, and I needed something reliable that wouldn’t cost a fortune. After seeing the price point and the basic specifications, I thought the Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog might fit the bill.
Out of the package, the Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog is surprisingly simple. The black leather construction looks decent enough, although it lacks the visual appeal of more elaborate frogs. At 5.75″ x 3.5″, it’s fairly compact. My initial impression was that it was sturdy but basic.
Compared to more expensive, hand-stitched leather frogs, the Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog is clearly a budget option. I’ve used custom-made frogs that offer superior leather quality and craftsmanship, but they come at a significant cost. This frog seemed more practical for basic carrying needs compared to some nylon options I’ve seen that lack the aesthetic appeal for historical settings.
My first impression was cautiously optimistic. The simplicity was appealing, and the leather looked sturdy enough. I was hoping that its performance would justify its no-frills design and affordable price.
Real-World Testing: Putting Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog to the Test
First Use Experience
I first tested the Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog at a historical reenactment event where I needed to carry a broadsword for several hours. I attached it to my belt and secured the sword. The initial fit seemed snug, and I was able to move around without the sword feeling unstable.
The conditions were mostly dry, but the ground was uneven, and I had to navigate through crowded areas. The frog held up well, but I noticed some slight shifting of the sword within the frog as I walked. It was easy enough to adjust, but it was something I had to be mindful of.
Using the frog was relatively straightforward. The simple design meant there wasn’t much of a learning curve. Just slide the sword in and make sure it’s securely positioned.
After a couple of hours of use, I did notice some slight stretching of the leather around the sword’s point. While not a major issue, it was a sign that the leather might not be as robust as I initially thought.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several weeks of use in various reenactment and stage practice sessions, the Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog has shown some wear and tear. The leather has softened and stretched slightly more. The stitching remains intact, which is a positive.
There are a few minor scuffs and scratches on the leather from regular use, but nothing major. The biggest concern is the continued stretching around the sword’s point, which could potentially lead to the sword slipping out if not properly adjusted.
Cleaning is simple, requiring only a quick wipe-down with a damp cloth. I applied some leather conditioner to prevent further drying and cracking. Maintenance is minimal.
Compared to a previous, more expensive frog I used, the Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog is not as durable. My previous frog, made of thicker, higher-quality leather, lasted for years with minimal wear. This one feels like it will require more frequent replacement, but given the price difference, that’s a trade-off I expected.
Breaking Down the Features of Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog
Specifications
The Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog measures 5.75″ x 3.5″. It is constructed from leather and comes in black. The frog weighs only 0.2 lb.
These specifications indicate a lightweight and compact design intended for easy carry. The leather construction suggests a balance between durability and cost-effectiveness. The dimensions are suitable for a standard broadsword, but larger swords might not fit comfortably.
Performance & Functionality
The Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog does its job adequately. It securely holds the sword in place, allowing for hands-free carry. The simplicity of the design makes it easy to use.
The main strength is its affordability and ease of use. The weakness is the potential for the leather to stretch and wear over time. It meets basic expectations for a budget-friendly sword frog, but it doesn’t exceed them.
Design & Ergonomics
The Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog features a simple, no-frills design. The black leather offers a classic look. Its light weight makes it comfortable to wear for extended periods.
The build quality is adequate, but not exceptional. The leather is relatively thin, and the stitching is basic. The design is user-friendly, with no complicated straps or buckles.
Durability & Maintenance
The Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog is not designed for heavy-duty use. With regular use, it will likely last a few years before needing replacement. Proper maintenance, such as regular cleaning and conditioning, will help extend its lifespan.
Maintaining it is simple, requiring only occasional cleaning and conditioning. Repairs, if needed, would likely involve restitching or replacing the leather, which could be costly relative to the frog’s initial price.
Accessories and Customization Options
The Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog does not come with any accessories. There are no customization options available. Due to its simple design, it is not easily compatible with accessories from other brands.
Pros and Cons of Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog
Pros
- Affordable price point makes it accessible for budget-conscious users.
- Simple and easy to use.
- Lightweight and comfortable to wear for extended periods.
- Classic black leather design is suitable for various historical reenactments and stage productions.
- Functional for basic sword-carrying needs.
Cons
- Leather is relatively thin and may stretch or wear over time.
- Limited durability compared to higher-end leather frogs.
- No accessories or customization options.
Who Should Buy Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog?
The Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog is perfect for reenactors on a budget. It’s also good for stage performers needing a simple, functional sword-carrying solution. It’s suitable for casual sword enthusiasts who don’t require a high-end, durable frog.
Anyone needing a frog for frequent, rigorous use or requiring superior durability should skip this product. Those wanting a more elaborate or customizable frog should also look elsewhere. A leather balm is a must-have to keep the leather supple.
Conclusion on Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog
The Rite Edge Broad Sword Frog is a basic, affordable option for carrying a broadsword. While it lacks the durability and features of more expensive frogs, it gets the job done. The price is justified for those on a tight budget.
I would recommend it for casual users or those needing a temporary solution. For serious reenactors or those requiring long-lasting durability, investing in a higher-quality frog is worthwhile. It’s a good starting point, but be aware of its limitations. If you need a cheap, functional solution now, this works.