Let’s Talk About the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear
The Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear promises a compact, versatile tool for survival situations. Marketed as more than just a spear, its hollow handle with a survival kit and compatibility with broom handles aim to expand its utility. I was intrigued by its potential for both hunting and self-defense, combined with its packable size.
My search began with the need for a lightweight, multi-purpose tool for backcountry trips. I wanted something that could serve as a walking stick, a hunting implement, and a self-defense option, all while being easily carried. Unboxing revealed a relatively lightweight spear, the black finish on the 3Cr13 stainless steel blade looking surprisingly durable for the price. The hollow handle felt sturdy, and the screw-off cap revealed a basic but potentially useful survival kit.
I considered the Cold Steel Mini Boar Spear and the SOG Survival Hawk as alternatives. I chose the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear due to its compact size and included survival kit, factors that the others lacked. My initial impression was cautiously optimistic; it seemed like a good value for the price, but I needed to see how it performed in the field.
Real-World Testing: Putting the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear to the Test
First Use Experience
I tested the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear during a weekend backpacking trip in the Appalachian Mountains. The conditions were mixed, with periods of rain and sunshine, and temperatures ranging from 40 to 60 degrees Fahrenheit. I primarily used it as a walking stick and for light probing of the terrain ahead.
The spear performed adequately as a walking stick, though its shorter length (14″ overall) required me to hunch over slightly. In wet conditions, the handle became a little slippery, reducing grip confidence. After my first use, I noticed the compass on the screw-off cap was off by about 10 degrees.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several months of use, the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear shows some signs of wear. The black finish on the blade has scratched in several places, especially from contact with rocks and branches. The threads on the screw-off cap feel a little gritty, needing cleaning and lubrication.
Cleaning the spear is relatively easy, requiring just soap and water to remove dirt and grime. Compared to my previous experience with a Cold Steel Bushman spear, the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear doesn’t have the same robustness, but it also doesn’t have the same weight or price point. It seems appropriate for light-duty tasks, but I wouldn’t rely on it for heavy-duty survival situations.
Breaking Down the Features of the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear
Specifications
- The Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear has an overall length of 14 inches, making it highly packable.
- The blade is 8 inches long and made of 3Cr13 stainless steel with a black finish and a partially serrated edge.
- The blade is double-edged. This design enhances its piercing capability, but also increases the risk of accidental cuts if not handled carefully.
- The handle is hollow and threaded to accept most broom handles. This feature allows for extended reach and leverage when needed.
- A screw-off cap at the end of the handle reveals a small survival kit containing a compass (questionable accuracy), matches, and a small amount of fishing line and hooks. The survival kit is a nice addition, but its limited contents necessitate supplementing with a more comprehensive kit.
Performance & Functionality
The Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear functions adequately as a short spear or improvised knife. Its relatively short length limits its range and effectiveness as a spear for hunting larger game. The partially serrated blade is useful for sawing through small branches or rope, but it complicates sharpening the main blade edge.
The hollow handle design, while adding versatility, slightly compromises the overall balance and heft of the spear. The survival kit is a welcome addition, but the quality and quantity of the included items are minimal, suggesting the need for supplemental preparedness gear. It meets basic expectations for a low-cost survival tool, but it doesn’t excel in any single area.
Design & Ergonomics
The Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear features a simple, utilitarian design. Its light weight makes it easy to carry, but its short length necessitates bending over when used as a walking stick. The handle’s diameter is comfortable for most hands, but the lack of texture can make it slippery when wet.
The screw-off cap is easy to access, although the threads feel a bit rough. There is a slight learning curve to using a spear effectively, but this is not specific to this product.
Durability & Maintenance
The 3Cr13 stainless steel blade is reasonably durable for its price point, but it is prone to scratching and may require frequent sharpening. The black finish is purely cosmetic and wears off easily. The hollow handle appears to be made of a robust polymer.
Maintenance is straightforward, requiring only occasional cleaning and lubrication of the threads. Replacement of the compass and survival kit components might be necessary over time, especially if they get damaged or used.
Accessories and Customization Options
The Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear comes with a basic black nylon belt sheath. There are no included accessories beyond the items in the survival kit (compass, matches, fishing line and hooks). The primary customization option is the ability to attach a broom handle or similar pole to extend the spear’s reach.
There are no official accessories from Elk Ridge for this spear. However, aftermarket compasses, survival kits, and handle grips could potentially be adapted to fit.
Pros and Cons of the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear
Pros
- Affordable price point, making it accessible for budget-conscious buyers.
- Compact and lightweight design, ideal for backpacking and carrying in a survival kit.
- Hollow handle design allows for attachment to broom handles, increasing versatility.
- Included survival kit adds a basic level of preparedness, though limited in scope.
- Double edged blade enhances piercing capability.
Cons
- The compass accuracy is questionable, reducing its reliability in navigation.
- The survival kit is limited and should be supplemented with additional gear.
- The 3Cr13 stainless steel blade is prone to scratching and may require frequent sharpening.
Who Should Buy the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear?
The Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear is perfect for casual campers, budget-conscious hikers, and those looking for a supplemental survival tool. It is ideal for individuals who want a lightweight, multi-functional option for self-defense, light hunting, or general utility in the outdoors. This can be a starting point for someone building a survival kit on a budget.
This product should be skipped by experienced survivalists, hunters seeking a reliable hunting spear, or those needing a high-quality, durable tool for demanding tasks. Must-have accessories include a reliable compass, a more comprehensive survival kit, and potentially a better-quality sheath.
Conclusion on the Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear
The Elk Ridge Evolution Survival Spear is a decent entry-level survival tool with a compelling price point. Its versatility, thanks to the hollow handle and included survival kit, makes it a worthwhile consideration for casual outdoor enthusiasts. However, its limitations in durability and the questionable quality of some components mean it shouldn’t be considered a primary survival tool for serious situations.
The price of $53.49 is justified for what you get: a multi-functional tool with basic survival capabilities. I would recommend it for someone starting out or looking for a secondary tool for their outdoor adventures. Don’t expect miracles, but for the price, it’s a decent addition to your kit. Pick one up and see if it fits your needs, but remember to supplement it with better quality survival gear for true peace of mind in the wild.