Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster Review

Let’s Talk About Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster

The Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster presents itself as a versatile and premium option for concealed and open carry. Crafted by Versacarry from vegetable-tanned water buffalo leather, it boasts a raised protective backing, adjustable tension, and the ability to fit most handguns.

I needed a holster that could adapt to both inside-the-waistband (IWB) and outside-the-waistband (OWB) carry, depending on the situation. The Versacarry Protector S3 seemed to offer this flexibility with a touch of class, promising handcrafted quality and a comfortable carry experience.

Upon unboxing, I was immediately struck by the holster’s aesthetics; the distressed brown water buffalo leather looked rich and felt substantial. The stitching appeared clean and robust, suggesting a well-made product, and the overall design felt both classic and functional.

Compared to a Galco leather OWB holster I’ve used for years and a hybrid IWB from Crossbreed, the Versacarry Protector S3 stood out with its claimed universal fit and its promise of being equally suitable for both carry styles. I was particularly drawn to the adjustable tension feature, hoping for a more secure and customizable fit than my previous holsters offered.

My first impression was cautiously optimistic, the holster looked fantastic and felt good in hand, yet the “universal fit” claim always makes me slightly skeptical. I was eager to test its real-world functionality and see if it lived up to the initial promise of quality and versatility.

Check Best Price HERE

Real-World Testing: Putting Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster to the Test

First Use Experience

I tested the Versacarry Protector S3 primarily at the shooting range and during everyday carry scenarios. I wore it both IWB at the 4 o’clock position and OWB during range sessions, attempting to assess its comfort, security, and ease of access.

Initially, I experienced no adverse conditions; the weather was fair and dry, providing optimal conditions for evaluating the holster’s basic functionality. The draw stroke felt relatively smooth, although I noticed a slight “stickiness” that I hoped would improve with break-in.

The first surprise came when I transitioned from IWB to OWB carry; the belt clip felt less secure than I anticipated, exhibiting a noticeable wiggle. Moreover, the user feedback I had read about a loose clip screw came to fruition on my first use.

Extended Use & Reliability

After a few weeks of consistent use, the Versacarry Protector S3 began to show some signs of wear, mostly in the form of scuff marks on the leather from repeated draws. While the leather itself seemed durable, the hardware became a persistent concern.

The adjustable tension screw required frequent tightening, and the belt clip screw continued to loosen despite my best efforts to secure it with thread locker. Cleaning was simple; I used a leather cleaner and conditioner to maintain the leather’s appearance and prevent it from drying out.

Compared to my older, more established holsters, the Versacarry Protector S3 underperformed in terms of long-term reliability. The constant need to adjust and tighten screws undermined my confidence in its ability to securely retain my firearm in a critical situation.

Breaking Down the Features of Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster

Specifications

• The Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster is designed with a Universal fit, meant to accommodate a wide range of handguns. This adaptability is a core selling point.
• It is constructed from Water Buffalo Leather, known for its durability and unique grain. The leather is vegetable-tanned.
• Designed exclusively for Right-Handed users, limiting its appeal. This is a significant constraint for left-handed shooters.
• The holster offers both Outside the Waistband Holster, Inside the Waistband Holster carry options. It uses a Hook, Belt Clip accessory attachment system.
• It accommodates a 1.5-inch belt, a standard size for most gun belts. It features an Open Top design.
• The holster features Adjustable Tension. This allows users to customize the level of retention.

These specifications promised a versatile, comfortable, and secure carry experience. However, the real-world performance revealed some shortcomings in execution and reliability.

Performance & Functionality

The Versacarry Protector S3 functions adequately as a holster, retaining the firearm and allowing for a relatively smooth draw. However, the need for constant adjustment and tightening significantly detracts from its overall performance.

Its strengths lie in its aesthetic appeal and initial comfort; it looks and feels good when first worn. The primary weakness is the unreliable hardware.

The Versacarry Protector S3 meets basic expectations for a holster but falls short of exceeding them due to the aforementioned hardware issues. The loosening screws erode user confidence.

Design & Ergonomics

The build quality is generally good, with high-quality leather and clean stitching. However, the design of the belt clip attachment point feels somewhat flimsy and prone to loosening.

The Versacarry Protector S3 is user-friendly, requiring minimal learning curve for basic operation. However, the constant need to make adjustments and fix loose screws can be frustrating.

Durability & Maintenance

The leather itself appears durable and should last for a considerable time with proper care. However, the longevity of the hardware is questionable.

Maintenance is simple, requiring only occasional cleaning and conditioning of the leather. Repairing or replacing the hardware may be necessary over time.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster comes with no additional accessories. This lack of additional items is disappointing.

It is not explicitly designed for customization with aftermarket parts, but the universal fit may allow for some modifications. Swapping the belt clip may be a potential upgrade.

Pros and Cons of Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster

Check Best Price HERE

Who Should Buy Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster?

The Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster is perfect for individuals who prioritize aesthetics and initial comfort in a holster, and who are willing to perform regular maintenance and adjustments. Those seeking a stylish leather holster for occasional or light-duty use may find it appealing.

Individuals who require a highly reliable and durable holster for daily carry or tactical applications should skip this product. Law enforcement, security personnel, or anyone who relies on their firearm for self-defense in high-stress situations may find the hardware issues unacceptable.

A must-have modification would be to replace the factory screws with higher-quality alternatives and to apply a more durable thread locker. Upgrading the belt clip would also enhance its overall security and longevity.

Conclusion on Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster

The Versacarry Protector S3 IWB/OWB Holster is a mixed bag, offering a visually appealing design and initial comfort but ultimately falling short on reliability. The loosening screws and questionable hardware undermine its value proposition.

At $48.98, the price is relatively affordable for a leather holster, but the cost of potential repairs and modifications should be factored in. The price is barely justified.

I would be hesitant to recommend it without reservations; potential buyers should be aware of the hardware issues and be prepared to address them proactively. While the Versacarry Protector S3 has its merits, its flaws are significant enough to warrant careful consideration before purchasing. If you’re willing to tinker and upgrade, it could be a decent option, but there are more reliable choices available at a similar price point.